Closed mrheinen closed 5 days ago
Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
β±οΈ Estimated effort to review: 3 π΅π΅π΅βͺβͺ |
π§ͺ PR contains tests |
π No security concerns identified |
β‘ Recommended focus areas for review Potential Bug The code appends SSL ports to the regular ports array instead of the SSL ports array. This may lead to incorrect port reporting. Performance Concern The code recreates the entire ports and SSL ports arrays on each status update, which may be inefficient for frequent updates. Code Smell The port formatting logic in the watch hook is repetitive and could be refactored into a separate method for better maintainability. |
Failed to generate code suggestions for PR
Explore these optional code suggestions:
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Enhancement |
Directly assign new port values instead of appending to empty slices___ **Instead of appending to empty slices, directly assign the new values tohp.Ports and hp.SSLPorts . This is more efficient and clearer.**
[pkg/backend/backend.go [336-337]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/68/files#diff-c65bcfe9bb457434c3e69ba3f0576d7669935f350d24e2c2c58b05b4f9c510b2R336-R337)
```diff
-hp.Ports = append(hp.Ports, req.GetListenPort()...)
-hp.SSLPorts = append(hp.Ports, req.GetListenPortSsl()...)
+hp.Ports = req.GetListenPort()
+hp.SSLPorts = req.GetListenPortSsl()
```
- [ ] **Apply this suggestion**
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: This suggestion improves code efficiency and readability by directly assigning values instead of unnecessary append operations on empty slices. | 8 |
β Simplify port assignment by directly assigning new values instead of clearing and appending___Suggestion Impact:The commit implemented the suggestion by replacing the slice clearing and appending operations with direct assignments for both Ports and SSLPorts. code diff: ```diff dms[0].Ports = []int64{} - dms[0].Ports = append(dms[0].Ports, req.GetListenPort()...) + dms[0].Ports = req.GetListenPort() dms[0].SSLPorts = []int64{} - dms[0].SSLPorts = append(dms[0].SSLPorts, req.GetListenPortSsl()...) + dms[0].SSLPorts = req.GetListenPortSsl() ```for dms[0].Ports and dms[0].SSLPorts .**
[pkg/backend/backend.go [349-353]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/68/files#diff-c65bcfe9bb457434c3e69ba3f0576d7669935f350d24e2c2c58b05b4f9c510b2R349-R353)
```diff
-dms[0].Ports = []int64{}
-dms[0].Ports = append(dms[0].Ports, req.GetListenPort()...)
+dms[0].Ports = req.GetListenPort()
+dms[0].SSLPorts = req.GetListenPortSsl()
-dms[0].SSLPorts = []int64{}
-dms[0].SSLPorts = append(dms[0].SSLPorts, req.GetListenPortSsl()...)
-
```
- [ ] **Apply this suggestion**
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: This change eliminates redundant operations, making the code more concise and efficient while maintaining the same functionality. | 8 | |
β Simplify port string creation by using the join method instead of manual concatenation___Suggestion Impact:The commit directly implemented the suggestion by replacing the manual string concatenation with the join() method for both localPorts and localSSLPorts code diff: ```diff - this.localHoneypot.ports.forEach((port) => { - if (this.localPorts == "") { - this.localPorts += port; - } else { - this.localPorts += ", " + port; - } - }) - - this.localHoneypot.ssl_ports.forEach((port) => { - if (this.localSSLPorts == "") { - this.localSSLPorts += port; - } else { - this.localSSLPorts += ", " + port; - } - }) + this.localPorts = this.localHoneypot.ports.join(", "); + this.localSSLPorts = this.localHoneypot.ssl_ports.join(", "); ```localPorts and localSSLPorts with the join() method, which is more concise and efficient.**
[ui/src/components/container/HoneypotForm.vue [189-203]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/68/files#diff-e333339a49f1250cbbff50f56916c5c3c731bf7e1eb349da1553bee56dc119d7R189-R203)
```diff
-this.localHoneypot.ports.forEach((port) => {
- if (this.localPorts == "") {
- this.localPorts += port;
- } else {
- this.localPorts += ", " + port;
- }
-})
+this.localPorts = this.localHoneypot.ports.join(", ");
+this.localSSLPorts = this.localHoneypot.ssl_ports.join(", ");
-this.localHoneypot.ssl_ports.forEach((port) => {
- if (this.localSSLPorts == "") {
- this.localSSLPorts += port;
- } else {
- this.localSSLPorts += ", " + port;
- }
-})
-
```
- [ ] **Apply this suggestion**
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Using the join method is more concise and efficient than manual string concatenation, improving code readability and performance. | 7 | |
Use a map to track ports and their SSL status instead of separate slices___ **Consider using a map to track SSL and non-SSL ports instead of separate slices. Thisapproach can simplify the code and potentially improve performance when checking if a port is SSL or not.** [pkg/agent/agent.go [80-84]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/68/files#diff-18bf746206c8ac217eb16ffb0cf91a6e676e05a7b517dc70aef0260d0871028fR80-R84) ```diff -if s.ssl { - a.sslPorts = append(a.sslPorts, s.port) -} else { - a.ports = append(a.ports, s.port) -} +a.ports[s.port] = s.ssl ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: While this suggestion could potentially improve performance for port lookups, it changes the data structure significantly. The benefit may not outweigh the cost of refactoring other parts of the code that rely on the current structure. | 6 |
π‘ Need additional feedback ? start a PR chat
User description
This PR finalizes the functionality where honeypots report the ports they listen on via the Status RPC. The ports are then stored in the database and displayed in the honeypot tab in the web UI
PR Type
Enhancement
Description
This PR implements the functionality for honeypots to report the ports they listen on and stores this information in the database. The main changes include:
These changes enable better tracking and display of honeypot configurations, improving system monitoring and management capabilities.
Changes walkthrough π
agent.go
Add port reporting to Agent
pkg/agent/agent.go
ports
andsslPorts
fields to theAgent
structStart
method to populate these fieldsSendStatus
call to includeListenPort
andListenPortSsl
backend.go
Implement port storage in backend
pkg/backend/backend.go
SendStatus
function to handle and store reported portsinformation
database.go
Add port fields to Honeypot struct
pkg/database/database.go
Ports
andSSLPorts
fields to theHoneypot
structpgtype.FlatArray[int64]
string_map_cache.go
Generalize StringMapCache implementation
pkg/util/string_map_cache.go
StringMapCache
and related functions to use generic typeT
any
instead ofT comparable
HoneypotForm.vue
Add port display to Honeypot form
ui/src/components/container/HoneypotForm.vue
database.sql
Update honeypot table schema
config/database.sql
ports
andssl_ports
columns to thehoneypot
tablecves
column to thehoneypot
tablebackend_test.go
Update backend tests for port handling
pkg/backend/backend_test.go
ListenPort
andListenPortSsl
in requests