[bug] Remapping is ignored on both ROS1 and ROS2

[sandilyasg]

(Please add appropriate labels)

• [ ] Linux: (Ubuntu 18.04)
• [ ] ROS 1: Melodic

\<Version of the plugin> v0.8.4

\<Copy the Version information from the Help | About menu> Version: 1.82.2 Commit: abd2f3db4bdb28f9e95536dfa84d8479f1eb312d Date: 2023-09-14T05:51:20.981Z Electron: 25.8.1 ElectronBuildId: 23779380 Chromium: 114.0.5735.289 Node.js: 18.15.0 V8: 11.4.183.29-electron.0 OS: Linux x64 5.4.0-150-generic snap

what is the bug

\<current behavior> I get the following error from VS code debugger: "Error from roslaunch: WARN: unrecognized 'remap' tag in tag"

Repro steps

\<how to reproduce the bug. Please attach sample files or github repo if appropriate.>

1. I have 2 main launch files, one that I launch from the linux terminal, and one via the launch.json in VS Code (both shown below). Launched in VS code: master_rag_simulation.launch: `

`

Launched from terminal: master_rag_sim_terminal.launch:

`

` When I launch this file, particularly the "multi_karto_gtsam_posfilter.launch" file, I get the following error from VS code:

"Error from roslaunch: WARN: unrecognized 'remap' tag in tag"

This is what my multi_karto_gtsam_posfilter.launch file looks like: `

<include file="$(find turtlebot3_slam)/launch/turtlebot3_karto_gtsam.launch">
  <!-- <arg name="output_to_screen" value="log"/> -->
  <arg name="output_to_screen" value="screen"/>
  <arg name="ns" value="tb3_0"/>
  <remap from="/$(arg ns)/scan" to="/$(arg ns)/scan_filtered"/>
</include>

<include file="$(find turtlebot3_slam)/launch/turtlebot3_karto_gtsam.launch">
  <arg name="output_to_screen" value="log"/>
  <arg name="ns" value="tb3_1"/>
  <remap from="/$(arg ns)/scan" to="/$(arg ns)/scan_filtered"/>
</include>

<include file="$(find turtlebot3_slam)/launch/turtlebot3_karto_gtsam.launch">
  <arg name="output_to_screen" value="log"/>
  <arg name="ns" value="tb3_2"/>
  <remap from="/$(arg ns)/scan" to="/$(arg ns)/scan_filtered"/>
</include>

`

expected behavior

\<what you would expect to happen> I expect to see no error or warning, and the debugger steps through breakpoints in the C++ nodes.

additional context

\<any additional information would be helpful for a better understanding> I see that this error originates from tools/roslaunch/src/roslaunch/xmlloader.py, line 583. When I run the launch files from my terminal, they work correctly with no errors.

[xoofee]

I met the same problem with python launch file. Ros extension in VSCODE ignore the remappings in launch.py when start debuging

If run command in terminal, it has no problem

[sandilyasg]

@xoofee what do you mean Python launch file? As in you have a .launch file which includes a python node? Yes if run from the terminal, this remapping problem does not occur. Would be nice to get it to work in VS code ROS extension

[xoofee]

yes, I mean xxx.launch.py file in python format, this is an example

`from launch import LaunchDescription from launch_ros.actions import Node

def generate_launch_description(): return LaunchDescription([ Node( package='ros_test', namespace='', executable='ros_test_node', remappings=[ ('~/input', '/localization/kinematic_state'), ]
), ]) `

However, if I do not use the tilde ~/ in my topic name, just 'input', the VS code ROS extension has no problem for the remap.

[sandilyasg]

@xoofee thanks for your reply. Where do I find this .launch.py file, is it generated for any .launch file that I have or did you specifically create it yourself for use with VSCode ROS extension?

[ooeygui]

Just to confirm -This looks like it repros on both ROS1 and ROS2?