msdogan / HOBBEStoPRMcomparison

HOBBES to PRM CALVIN run comparison
1 stars 0 forks source link

Create a new run after adding missing penalties #10

Closed msdogan closed 8 years ago

msdogan commented 8 years ago

@jrmerz @jdherman @mimijenkins1 @whiteellie @mfefer

While comparing penalty data between CALVIN and HOBBES, I saw that test (HOBBES) has some missing penalty data.

Missing penalty data links/nodes:

I guess, at this point, we need to add missing penalties to HOBBES, and run again, and then compare results.

mimijenkins1 commented 8 years ago

Ah... the missing SURP_DELTA flow penalty could explain the extra 40
TAF/yr delivery to C-MWD!

On Fri, 23 Sep 2016 16:26:10 -0700, Mustafa Dogan
notifications@github.com wrote:

@jrmerz @jdherman @mimijenkins1 @whiteellie @mfefer

While comparing penalty data between CALVIN and HOBBES, I saw that test
(HOBBES) has some missing penalty data.

Missing penalty data links/nodes: D541-SURP_DELTA SR_DMV SR_MHV SR_SKN

I guess, at this point, we need to add missing penalties to HOBBES, and
run again, and then compare results.

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or mute the thread.

Marion W. Jenkins, PhD Associate Research Engineer Dept. Civil & Environmental Engineering Ghausi Hall, Rm 3019 University of California at Davis Davis, CA 95616 Tel: +1 530 754 6427 Fax: +1 530 752 7872

jdherman commented 8 years ago

Hey, good eye Mustafa! Maybe this will do the trick!

msdogan commented 8 years ago

Dear all,

Based on the initial postprocessing results, adding those missing penalties changed results slightly but did not do the trick we want. Latest run has about 4 taf/m less surplus delta outflow than S09I05. There is probably still missing some other things in somewhere.

TAF/y   S09I05  test    test_round  test_round_penalty(latest_run)
Total Delta Exports 6833    6872    6877    6877
Surp. Delta Outflow 9196    9142    9147    9153