mtyeh411 / mediawiki-bootstrap

A customizable responsive Bootstrap MediaWiki skin.
GNU General Public License v2.0
78 stars 19 forks source link

Firefox Login doesnt work #18

Closed alexalspach closed 11 years ago

alexalspach commented 11 years ago

Hello!

First of all, great job. This had made out company product wiki look great and I'm having fun customizing the new page.

In chrome and safari, when logged out, the user drop down menu at the top right (the orange one) shows the ip address of the user and the drop down has a login link. On firefox, a link saying "log in" shows but does not load the login page when clicked. Hopefully this is a simple fix but until then, it inhibits the editing of the page unless I add a login link elsewhere.

Thanks again for some great software!

Alex

mtyeh411 commented 11 years ago

I do notice (at least in Firefox) that the skin shows 'create account' rather than the IP address by default for unauthenticated users. However, I'm still able to link through to the login page.

The links are generated from MediaWiki BaseTemplate class, which would be shared among all skins.

Is this a public wiki?

alexalspach commented 11 years ago

This is a public view-only wiki. So users are unable to make an account on their own. Therefore, in firefox, the link up top says "Log in" and doesnt click through to the log in page. Check it out on my wiki: simlab.co.kr/AllegroHand/wiki

Thanks.

Alex

On Tue, Feb 26, 2013 at 10:27 PM, mtyeh411 notifications@github.com wrote:

I do notice (at least in Firefox) that the skin shows 'create account' rather than the IP address by default for unauthenticated users. However, I'm still able to link through to the login page.

The links are generated from MediaWiki BaseTemplate class, which would be shared among all skins.

Is this a public wiki?

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/mtyeh411/mediawiki-bootstrap/issues/18#issuecomment-14113168 .

mtyeh411 commented 11 years ago

First up, the link anchor to log in link is not tied to button, but to the text. This is not desirable, and will be fixed very soon. My guess is that you were clicking the button (rather than the "Log in" text)? I'll open another issue regarding that.

As far as "Log in" showing with no dropdown, this isn't a Firefox-specific issue. It has to do with MediaWiki cookies and which links they generate based on said cookies. Clear your cookies in Chrome/Safari and you should see the same behavior. Assuming typical MediaWiki installation (ie, no extensions installed that change login behavior): upon visit to log in page, MediaWiki will log your IP address and use that as user account for visitors (in your case with read-only permission). I'll be sure to account for these behaviors in a future update as well. I will reference this issue (#18) when that is fixed.

Thanks for pointing these out.

PS, great looking wiki!

alexalspach commented 11 years ago

Thanks for the compliment.

Unfortunately, I realized that the link is only in text and not the entire button. Still, in firefox, the Login button up top contains no link at all. Not even text.

Once logged in, this problem continues and the user name link that replaces the login link is just text - no link. When you visited my site: http://simlab.dyndns.org:9000/AllegroHandWiki/index.php/Allegro_Hand on your computer, were you able to click Login at the top?

Thanks.

Alex

On Fri, Mar 1, 2013 at 6:53 AM, mtyeh411 notifications@github.com wrote:

First up, the link anchor to log in link is not tied to button, but to the text. This is not desirable, and will be fixed very soon. My guess is that you were clicking the button (rather than the "Log in" text)? I'll open another issue regarding that.

As far as "Log in" showing with no dropdown, this isn't a Firefox-specific issue. It has to do with MediaWiki cookies and which links they generate based on said cookies. Clear your cookies in Chrome/Safari and you should see the same behavior. Assuming typical MediaWiki installation (ie, no extensions installed that change login behavior): upon visit to log in page, MediaWiki will log your IP address and use that as user account for visitors (in your case with read-only permission). I'll be sure to account for these behaviors in a future update as well. I will reference this issue (#18 https://github.com/mtyeh411/mediawiki-bootstrap/issues/18) when that is fixed.

Thanks for pointing these out.

PS, great looking wiki!

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/mtyeh411/mediawiki-bootstrap/issues/18#issuecomment-14259944 .

mtyeh411 commented 11 years ago

Yes. Able to link to login page.

alexalspach commented 11 years ago

Ive tested this on multiple computers. Mac, PC, Linux. What could be the difference between your situation and mine?

On Tue, Mar 5, 2013 at 12:01 PM, mtyeh411 notifications@github.com wrote:

Yes. Able to link to login page.

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/mtyeh411/mediawiki-bootstrap/issues/18#issuecomment-14420865 .