search

mulesoft / api-designer

A web editor for creating and sharing RAML API specifications
Other
1.07k stars 268 forks source link

implement osprey as local mock service #269

Open xiaohanyu opened 9 years ago

xiaohanyu commented 9 years ago

Hi,

I'm using api-designer in my company with RAML and it works great. However, I have a question, how can it build a localhost mock service inside my company for RAML instead of using mock service from mulesoft?

I mean, is there some open source software that eats RAML and produces a mock service in localhost?

I know mulesoft's studio IDE, however, it has bugs with RAML's !include syntax.

Thanks!

sichvoge commented 9 years ago

Hi @xiaohanyu - the mocking service is not available on-premise, unfortunately. What you can do is using Anypoint Studio -> create a new project -> select APIkit and the RAML you would like to have a mocking of -> Finish. The APIkit automatically creates a flow application with flows for each http_verb:/resource and if you provide examples you get Set Payload components containing them by default. If you run the Mule app and do a request, you will get your examples back.

This should work fine as a workaround. You can even use it combined with Maven to automate this.

rezaloo commented 9 years ago

Hi Xiao,

Could you please provide more details around the Studio bugs that you are referring to?

Thanks,

Reza

On Thu, Dec 4, 2014 at 10:54 PM, Xiao Hanyu notifications@github.com wrote:

Hi,

I'm using api-designer in my company with RAML and it works great. However, I have a question, how can it build a localhost mock service inside my company for RAML instead of using mock service from mulesoft?

I mean, is there some open source software that eats RAML and produces a mock service in localhost?

I know mulesoft's studio IDE, however, it has bugs with RAML's !include syntax.

Thanks!

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/mulesoft/api-designer/issues/269.

Reza Shafii

Senior Director of Product Management - Anypoint Platform for APIs | MuleSoft http://www.mulesoft.com/

77 Geary Street, Suite 400 | San Francisco, CA 94108

Tel: +1 415-632-6525 reza.shafii@mulesoft.com | twitter.com/rezaloo

xiaohanyu commented 9 years ago

@sichvoge Thanks for your reply. I'm still wondering why not open source this type of mock service, I think it is much more better for the adoption of RAML spec if it has a open mock service running on localhost.

@rezaloo I'll paste some more info this day.

rezaloo commented 9 years ago

Great, thanks.

Reza

On Sun, Dec 7, 2014 at 10:07 PM, Xiao Hanyu notifications@github.com wrote:

@sichvoge https://github.com/sichvoge Thanks for your reply. I'm still wondering why not open source this type of mock service, I think it is much more better for the adoption of RAML spec if it has a open mock service running on localhost.

@rezaloo https://github.com/rezaloo I'll paste some more info this day.

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/mulesoft/api-designer/issues/269#issuecomment-65998760 .

Reza Shafii

Senior Director of Product Management - Anypoint Platform for APIs | MuleSoft http://www.mulesoft.com/

77 Geary Street, Suite 400 | San Francisco, CA 94108

Tel: +1 415-632-6525 reza.shafii@mulesoft.com | twitter.com/rezaloo

xiaohanyu commented 9 years ago

Hey, I've checked https://github.com/mulesoft/osprey , and it seems this is a mock service for localhost, any comments on this? Thanks!

dmartinezg commented 9 years ago

Hi @xiaohanyu, you are right, osprey does also provide mocking capabilities, which you can use.

jewelsjacobs commented 9 years ago

I have the two combined here: https://github.com/jewelsjacobs/raml-osprey-api-designer

usarid commented 9 years ago

Cool stuff Julia!

On Fri, Feb 27, 2015 at 8:49 AM, Julia Jacobs notifications@github.com wrote:

I have the two combined here: https://github.com/jewelsjacobs/raml-osprey-api-designer

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/mulesoft/api-designer/issues/269#issuecomment-76427150 .

sichvoge commented 9 years ago

Brilliant!

sichvoge commented 9 years ago

I will turning this to a enhancement request as it would be really nice to have osprey as the out of the box mocking service for the standalone designer.

jewelsjacobs commented 9 years ago

This has become very difficult for me to maintain with the updates to mongodb (3.0 and the native nodeJS driver), osprey and api-designer. Currently my project is broken. :confounded:

I could really use some help with this . . . :sob:

I've even had to investigate using API Blueprint as an alternative because my new gig wants a solution ASAP or they are going to ditch the idea of design first API development . . . :rage4:

HELP!!!!!

sichvoge commented 9 years ago

@jewelsjacobs, what kind of help do you need? let's do what ever we can to keep you w/ RAML ;)

jewelsjacobs commented 9 years ago

The full sad tale . . .

Here's my app:

https://github.com/jewelsjacobs/raml-osprey-api-designer

It's a mashup of osprey for mock data, mongoDB as a datasource, raml2html for documentation and api-designer as the RAML editor.

I wanted to update it so I could use the new api designer features (create new folders and export files). Because I'm using mongodb as a datasource, that requires some trickery in the api-designer's index.html file to keep it decoupled from the api-designer's app code. You can see my sad attempt here: - https://github.com/jewelsjacobs/raml-osprey-api-designer/blob/update-api-designer/app/index.html

My back end broke when mongoDB upgraded to 3+ along with the native nodeJS driver update so I made a sad attempt to update my files here:

The big disappointment was I had emailed the link of my raml-osprey-api-designer app repo to an Architect at Paypal who did a demo at an EnterpriseNodeJS meetup on swaggerize because he told me afterword he wanted to use RAML but couldn't find tools that worked well together and couldn't get buy in from his team. He forwarded my link to the API Director over there and the guy wanted me to do a demo of my app but it was too broken so I have not responded!

AAAAGGGGG!!!!!

TBH the Blueprint solution didn't work either because drakov, the mock data server, was not handling schema validations properly so now I'm demoing the Mulesoft Anypoint service to my co-workers next week. I've got to put a support ticket in with Mulesoft now too cause json request bodies which should be invalid due to the request schema definitions, are coming back with 400 HTTP code responses and not 422 as they should be, from the Mulesoft mock data server.

Here's the link to my question to Mulesoft BTW: http://gsfn.us/t/4qzqd

So that's the whole story.

Anyway I love RAML. It's the best.

sichvoge commented 9 years ago

Maybe you want to help us to get Osprey as the mocking server into the api-designer? @blakeembrey can you help here please.

Do you still need to do a demo to the PayPal guys or anyone else?

BTW, whats the name of the API Director at PayPal? Is it Jason Harmon by any chance?

jewelsjacobs commented 9 years ago

@sichvoge yup thats him, he sent me a twitter DM:

We just did Swagger last month, I figured we should do a RAML night in the next few months. Email me we can chat more

I just responded to his DM letting him know I was working on the update with some help from y'all and linked to this issue so he can keep up to date on the progress.

I'm demoing the Anysoft stuff next week at Boundary.

sichvoge commented 9 years ago

Sounds good, please let me know what I can do to help you! BTW, I will be not able to answer to you for the next couple of hours. I am in London and it's getting late ;)

sichvoge commented 7 years ago

@jewelsjacobs any news, its been a while :)

jewelsjacobs commented 7 years ago

Hi @sichvoge!

No progress on this I'm afraid. I got caught up in other stuff. Still following the progress of this project and trying to sell RAML + API Design everywhere I go!

sichvoge commented 7 years ago

Everywhere is awesome! :D Have you heard about the RAML MVP Program? You would make a great MVP ;)