musescore / MuseScore

MuseScore is an open source and free music notation software. For support, contribution, bug reports, visit MuseScore.org. Fork and make pull requests!
https://musescore.org
Other
12.23k stars 2.65k forks source link

"Show staff anyway" layout element #25127

Open tygoee opened 2 weeks ago

tygoee commented 2 weeks ago

Your idea

When writing (especially pre-engraved) orchestral pieces in Musescore, I use "Hide empty staves" to hide all empty staves. This works nicely, but there are sometimes reasons to show them anyway:

Problem to be solved

There's currently no way to do this in musescore. I've seen multiple questions on musescore.org about this topic #331110 #237664 #198946 and the answer is usually either 'that's not possible' or 'try this workaround'.

Prior art

Suggested workarounds I've seen are:

Besides this making export files sloppy, I also ran into an issue when creating parts: the multimeasure parts were broken apart. I tried to solve it, but after trying to hide/move/remove it individually from the main score i ended up creating seperate instruments/staves.

Additional context

In ons of these issues I recall seeing a Musescore team member/contributer respond that it would be nice if it had this feature, but I couldn't find the issue.

For reference, here is the transcribed file: Concerto_No._7_in_F_Major_K._242_Londron__Wolfgang_Amadeus_Mozart.mscz

Checklist

rpatters1 commented 2 weeks ago

I just posted this same issue today. It's a popular issue. #25107

DaddyLudwig commented 2 weeks ago

I generally use white text just saying Text to unhide hidden staves. I do that a lot in operas, cantatas, basically anything where the instrumentation changes from section to section.

tygoee commented 2 weeks ago

@DaddyLudwig I mentioned that, I do the same. But I'm sometimes also extracting parts and multimeasure rests break on rests