search

music-encoding / guidelines

:scroll: The Music Encoding Initiative Guidelines
Educational Community License v2.0
23 stars 29 forks source link

3.1.1.3: PhysDesc not allowed in fileDesc #120

Closed axgeertinger closed 2 years ago

axgeertinger commented 5 years ago

Chapter 3.1.1.3. "Physical Description of the File" should be renamed and the example corrected accordingly (remove physDesc)

musicEnfanthen commented 2 years ago

@rieede @doerners May I ask you to check if this is still an issue?

doerners commented 2 years ago

It still seems like an unsolved issue. The section is, however, most likely 3.4.1.2 Physical Description of the File and the respective example mentioned is most certainly Listing 44 (referring to the dev version of the guidelines). @riedde could you have a second look to check if I identified the right chapter/listing? I'll also link this issue within our project board.

riedde commented 2 years ago

yes, the referred chapter 3.1.1.2 has become 3.4.1.2.

Its still an Issue, since the data model has changed (seems like).

The section should be renamed, e.g., "Extent of the File" and Listing 44, as @doerners and already @axgeertinger mentioned, must be reworked (erasing physDesc). I will provide a PR for this.