Schumann_Op.41.mei

[bwbohl]

trills are encoded in a second layer with note missing @dur. These should be encoded as trills. One might wrap them in a mei:choice though, with mei:orig and mei:reg.

[pe-ro]

@bwbohl, I'm having trouble determining which trills you're talking about. Can you be more specific please?

[th-we]

@pe-ro These are the lines from this file:

• L1347–1385

  <measure n="10" xml:id="d968622e3808">
  <staff n="1">
  <layer n="1">
    <note xml:id="d968622e3811" pname="c" oct="5" dur="4" stem.dir="down"/>
    <note xml:id="d968622e3827" pname="g" oct="4" dur="2" stem.dir="up"/>
    <beam>
      <note xml:id="d968622e3848" grace="unacc" pname="f" accid="s" oct="4" dur="16"
        stem.dir="up"/>
      <note xml:id="d968622e3869" grace="unacc" pname="g" oct="4" dur="16"
        stem.dir="up"/>
    </beam>
    <note xml:id="d968622e3886" pname="g" oct="4" dur="4" stem.dir="up"/>
  </layer>
  <layer n="2">
    <space xml:id="d968622e3906"/>
    <note xml:id="d968622e3911" visible="false" pname="g" oct="4" stem.dir="up"/>
    <note xml:id="d968622e3923" visible="false" pname="a" oct="4" stem.dir="up"
      accid.ges="f"/>
    <note xml:id="d968622e3938" visible="false" pname="g" oct="4" stem.dir="up"/>
    <note xml:id="d968622e3950" visible="false" pname="a" oct="4" stem.dir="up"
      accid.ges="f"/>
    <note xml:id="d968622e3964" visible="false" pname="g" oct="4" stem.dir="up"/>
    <note xml:id="d968622e3976" visible="false" pname="a" oct="4" stem.dir="up"
      accid.ges="f"/>
    <note xml:id="d968622e3990" visible="false" pname="g" oct="4" stem.dir="up"/>
    <note xml:id="d968622e4002" visible="false" pname="a" oct="4" stem.dir="up"
      accid.ges="f"/>
    <note xml:id="d968622e4016" visible="false" pname="g" oct="4" stem.dir="up"/>
    <note xml:id="d968622e4031" visible="false" pname="a" oct="4" stem.dir="up"
      accid.ges="f"/>
    <note xml:id="d968622e4045" visible="false" pname="g" oct="4" stem.dir="up"/>
    <note xml:id="d968622e4057" visible="false" pname="a" oct="4" stem.dir="up"
      accid.ges="f"/>
    <note xml:id="d968622e4072" visible="false" pname="g" oct="4" stem.dir="up"/>
    <note xml:id="d968622e4084" visible="false" pname="a" oct="4" stem.dir="up"
      accid.ges="f"/>
    <note xml:id="d968622e4098" visible="false" pname="g" oct="4" stem.dir="up"/>
  </layer>
  </staff>
  <!-- ... -->
  </measure>

  

More lines like this:

• 1787–1830
• 2005–2033
• 2706–2720
• 3911–3939
• 4668–4682
• 8684–8698

I understand these lines to be "explorative" encoding by @KristinaRichts and @MajaHartwig from the early days of MEI. We could put them in a <choice> as @bwbohl suggests, but to me, the proper, metrically correct encoding is not entirely clear to me.

The lazy person that I am I would just delete them.