music-encoding / sibmei

Sibelius MEI Plugin
MIT License
40 stars 16 forks source link

Should expression text be output as <dynam>? #198

Open th-we opened 1 year ago

th-we commented 1 year ago

At the moment, Sibmei exports Expression text as <dynam>. Is that actually sensible? I guess e.g. "dolce" should be an Expression text, but should it be output as <dynam>, or rather as <dir>?

Suggested solutions:

th-we commented 1 year ago

This is of course not the whole picture as all the dynamics (forte, piano, ...) are input as Expression. We therefore have to analyize the content to generate <dynam> for those cases.

rettinghaus commented 1 year ago

For now we should leave expressions as they are and just make sure other sorts of texts are actually exported.

rettinghaus commented 1 year ago

Connected to #201