In docs/refs.md, reference WM13 was added. It is cited under opt_k_bisulfate in docs/co2sys_nd.md, but was missing from the reference list.
In docs/co2sys_nd.md, changes were made to the descriptions of some of the options for opt_k_carbonic. The reasons for these are described below, with the corresponding citations as headers (see docs/refs.md for full references).
CW98
Docs state real and artificial seawater used.
Methods (p. 659) describe collection and analysis of real seawater samples (see screenshot below), but there is no mention of artificial seawater.
Docs give the ranges 2 < T < 35 °C, 0 < S < 49 for this parameterisation.
Formulae used in the code are shown below (results, p. 661). Note that slightly different temperature ranges are given for the two pK formulae. I suggest using the range in which the two overlap, i.e., 2 < T < 30 °C. Note also the statement at the bottom, that the equations hold for salinities up to 40, not 49.
WMW14
Docs state ranges 0 < T < 50 °C, 1 < S < 50.
See highlighted line below (p. 16 in WM13). There is no eqn. 33 in the paper, but the contents of Table 6 (in both WM13 and WMW14) appear to correspond to eqns. 34-35, and these are the functions used in the code, so I believe the ranges stated below should be applied to this parameterisation.
SB21
Type of seawater used is not stated in the docs.
Materials section (p. 233) in the article states it was real seawater:
In
docs/refs.md, reference WM13 was added. It is cited underopt_k_bisulfateindocs/co2sys_nd.md, but was missing from the reference list.In
docs/co2sys_nd.md, changes were made to the descriptions of some of the options foropt_k_carbonic. The reasons for these are described below, with the corresponding citations as headers (seedocs/refs.mdfor full references).CW98
Docs state real and artificial seawater used. Methods (p. 659) describe collection and analysis of real seawater samples (see screenshot below), but there is no mention of artificial seawater.
Docs give the ranges 2 < T < 35 °C, 0 < S < 49 for this parameterisation. Formulae used in the code are shown below (results, p. 661). Note that slightly different temperature ranges are given for the two pK formulae. I suggest using the range in which the two overlap, i.e., 2 < T < 30 °C. Note also the statement at the bottom, that the equations hold for salinities up to 40, not 49.
WMW14
Docs state ranges 0 < T < 50 °C, 1 < S < 50. See highlighted line below (p. 16 in WM13). There is no eqn. 33 in the paper, but the contents of Table 6 (in both WM13 and WMW14) appear to correspond to eqns. 34-35, and these are the functions used in the code, so I believe the ranges stated below should be applied to this parameterisation.
SB21
Type of seawater used is not stated in the docs. Materials section (p. 233) in the article states it was real seawater: