search

mxpv / podsync

Turn YouTube or Vimeo channels, users, or playlists into podcast feeds
MIT License
1.5k stars 264 forks source link

Feeds Aren't Updating #37

Closed PaleZer0 closed 4 years ago

PaleZer0 commented 4 years ago

None of my feeds are updating at this point. If I recreate them it will pull the more recent episodes, but then those recreated ones won't update either.

iHack3x2 commented 4 years ago

Same here, last updated feed for me was October the 3rd and no real feedback on what's the problem/issue, so I could at least be understanding, honestly makes me feel as if there isn't going to be a solution.

scottkuhl commented 4 years ago

From the PodSync Twitter account:

Hello. YT is still blocking Podsync’s servers every time and I couldn’t find a way to bypass this and make it work stable considering amount of traffic we handle. Also I no longer can invest so much time in this project, apologies for not being able to answer all support requests

iHack3x2 commented 4 years ago

@scottkuhl thanks for the update, I wished this information was on the Podsync website or the Patreon.

If I might ask when was that tweet sent?

jeremytm commented 4 years ago

I previously used this, as well as youtube.videodeck.net... Both are now unavailable. Likely permanently. This is due to Youtube blocking more features from 3rd parties and keeping as many people as possible within youtube.com.

It's quite a shame, since it allows them to have more control over what they suggest to you, what they hide from you, etc. Hopefully they are doing this to protect against malicious agendas rather than to support their own.

scottkuhl commented 4 years ago

@scottkuhl thanks for the update, I wished this information was on the Podsync website or the Patreon.

If I might ask when was that tweet sent?

October 16th

scottkuhl commented 4 years ago

I previously used this, as well as youtube.videodeck.net... Both are now unavailable. Likely permanently. This is due to Youtube blocking more features from 3rd parties and keeping as many people as possible within youtube.com.

It's quite a shame, since it allows them to have more control over what they suggest to you, what they hide from you, etc. Hopefully they are doing this to protect against malicious agendas rather than to support their own.

I think it has everything to do with ads not being included in the downloads.

iHack3x2 commented 4 years ago

@scottkuhl @jeremytm yeah I can totally see why YouTube would be against this in the first place, it might be convenience for them but it isn't for me. I use a third party RSS reader and it allows me to just search who's in my feed including the description and it keeps me from getting sucked into the abyss that is YouTube.

But YouTube has naive RSS feeds, I might just go back to that. It just sucks that only like 10-15 are allowed at the start of the feed creation. I definitely would pay them a few extra bucks to be able to get an entire channels catalog into an RSS feed and allowed above 720p for streaming outside of Youtube.com.

scottkuhl commented 4 years ago

My backup plan has been going back to Feedly and using the RSS feed as well. I wish someone like PocketCasts would support YouTube channels. I understand they can't download the videos but they should be able to stream them.

focuspulling commented 4 years ago

@scottkuhl [edited message after clarification, sorry for the misunderstanding]

scottkuhl commented 4 years ago

@focuspulling

Just to be clear, I am not the developer of PodSync, @mxpv (Maksym Pavlenko) appears to be the developer. I am also a user. Just trying to inform others. I agree, if the site is no longer going to work and the developer has no plans on fixing it, the Patreon should be stopped.

focuspulling commented 4 years ago

@scottkuhl Hi Scott, really sorry about the misunderstanding. I had missed the central fact that you took initiative here at GitHub as a separate open source endeavor after Maksym Pavlenko abandoned PodSync while continuing to collect money. I'm already pursuing a complaint at Patreon and will make sure he stops profiting now that there is no continued service as promised. Meantime, I edited my comment above to avoid confusion.

I think I'm going to give Inoreader a go, which (at a somewhat more affordable Pro subscription compared to greedy Feedly) can accomplish this in combination with IFTTT.

mxpv commented 4 years ago

Podsync is still running at Podsync.net and handles download requests. And I still pay for the underlying resources. I don’t want to just shut it off as many people rely on it.

scottkuhl commented 4 years ago

@mxpv interesting. I thought YouTube was blocking it. How are users still relying on it?

mxpv commented 4 years ago

@scottkuhl Many users use Podsync to distribute podcasts (for example as a source URL for iTunes podcasts). Blocking part is related to episode downloader.

mxpv commented 4 years ago

Feeds Aren't Updating

issue to track https://github.com/mxpv/podsync/issues/38