nasa-gcn / gcn.nasa.gov

General Coordinates Network (GCN) web site
https://gcn.nasa.gov
Other
182 stars 43 forks source link

different circulars display depending on query #1293

Closed PiNuessle closed 1 year ago

PiNuessle commented 1 year ago

If query is entered as "YYMMDDA", then most relevant circulars are displayed, including future bursts referencing the queried burst. This should probably be noted as the preferred retrieval method. If query is entered as "YYMMDD", then no circulars are returned even when events are known to have occured. This should probably return data about the events associated with date, much as queries about "supernova" or "kilonova" return circulars that are associated with those events. If query is entered as "GRBYYMMDDA", then few if any circulars are displayed, and usually only future bursts which reference the queried burst. This should probably return the same as the burst name alone, rather than a very limited subset. If query is entered as "GRBYYMMDD", then no circulars are returned. This should probably return the same as the burst number alone, rather than nothing. If query is entered as "GRB YYMMDDA", then all GRB-adjacent notices ever entered into the GCN are displayed. This should probably be noted as the wrong way to enter GRB names, as it's really a database parsing issue.

jracusin commented 1 year ago

Pi, the search isn't parsing the date and using that to search, it's just searching for those strings. So when you just include YYMMDDL, it's finding any use of that. When you search GRBYYMMDDL, it's finding circulars where authors didn't include a space, and when you search "GRB YYMMDDL", it's searching for both "GRB" and "YYMMDDL". So it's working as intended, even if not intuitive.

We are working on searching by date, but that's still in progress. See #878.

PiNuessle commented 1 year ago

Okay, I’ll close the issue. Thank you!

Pi Nuessle They/them/theirs (español: elle, Nederlands: ze/hun) Physics Ph.D. Candidate George Washington University Higher Education Teaching M.Sc., Purdue University Global 2022 High-Performance Computing Masters Certificate, GWU 2021 B.Sc. Physics-Mathematics, Rose-Hulman 2018


From: Judy Racusin @.> Sent: Friday, August 25, 2023 6:19:51 PM To: nasa-gcn/gcn.nasa.gov @.> Cc: nuessle167 @.>; Author @.> Subject: Re: [nasa-gcn/gcn.nasa.gov] different circulars display depending on query (Issue #1293)

Pi, the search isn't parsing the date and using that to search, it's just searching for those strings. So when you just include YYMMDDL, it's finding any use of that. When you search GRBYYMMDDL, it's finding circulars where authors didn't include a space, and when you search "GRB YYMMDDL", it's searching for both "GRB" and "YYMMDDL". So it's working as intended, even if not intuitive.

We are working on searching by date, but that's still in progress. See #878https://github.com/nasa-gcn/gcn.nasa.gov/issues/878.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/nasa-gcn/gcn.nasa.gov/issues/1293#issuecomment-1693990660, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AS2THTADHYZ7ERGEEI3IPDDXXEQIPANCNFSM6AAAAAA367S6ZY. You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: @.***>

lpsinger commented 1 year ago

Is this, then, a duplicate of #878?

PiNuessle commented 1 year ago

this is a duplicate of #878