nasa-gcn / gcn.nasa.gov

General Coordinates Network (GCN) web site
https://gcn.nasa.gov
Other
182 stars 43 forks source link

Fix duplicate and incorrect ADS entries for GCN Circulars #2656

Open lpsinger opened 6 days ago

lpsinger commented 6 days ago

I sent the following to ADS:

Dear ADS,

We (the maintainers of the General Coordinates Network, https://gcn.nasa.gov/) have noticed some duplicated or incorrect ADS entries for GCN Circulars. There are two general categories:

There are between tens and hundreds of each category. What is the most efficient way to correct these ADS records?

Thanks, Leo

Originally posted by @lpsinger in https://github.com/nasa-gcn/gcn.nasa.gov/issues/2639#issuecomment-2445225867

lpsinger commented 12 hours ago

I received the following from ADS:

I can fix the 2nd category of problems in bulk. They should be correct after the weekend update.
For the first category of problems, it is usually because we got them from two different sources with conflicting author information (including whether the collaboration should be the author or not). Since we have no way to know which is correct, it would be best if you can send us that information - I just need to know which of the pair of bibcodes is the good one.

lpsinger commented 12 hours ago

I sent the following reply to ADS:

The second category is fixed now. For the first category, I don’t really see any systematic reason to keep one bibcode but not the other. And unfortunately, there are some Circulars for which both of the two corresponding duplicate ADS entries already have citations. What are the options for dealing with such entries?