netherspite
commented
6 years ago 
Sunday Jul 05, 2015 at 13:12 GMT
Felguard is doing almost the same dmg as other pets, he should be doing much more, it was reported that in T5 instances he is capable of 300-400 DPS.
In this link you can see people stating what dmg felguard does with certain amounts of spell dmg.
Link : http://www.wowhead.com/spell=30146/summon-felguard#comments:0
„With 700SP – 250-350 melee swings on cloth target“ On Corecraft my felguard does cca 170-220 melee swing on cloth targets with 800 Spell power.
Attack power that your pets get from your spell power is correct, which is 57%. The problem has to be in AP to DPS ratio or in felguards base weapon DPS. Lets find out – last post on this page:
http://wowmb.net/forums/f9/13262-felguard_how_use_what_wear/p5/
Thank god for this picture, we can gather some crucial data:
http://s23.photobucket.com/user/apep_wow/media/FG_3K_AP_052307.jpg.html
AP: 3146, as we can see it gives 224,7 DPS I did the math and on CC it would be the same number, the AP / DPS ratio is correct. This leaves us with basic weapon DPS that felguard does with 0 AP. It is too low.
From the Picture we can get the overall DPS very easily: Melee dmg is 763-819 and that is |[(819-763) / 2] + 763| /2 = 395,5 DPS (with + 20% +5% +5% modifiers from talent, soul link and MD -multiplicative stacking)
X + 0,2X = 395,5 ................ X = 329,58333333 X + 0,05X = 329,58333333 ............... X = 313,88888889 X + 0,05X = 313,88888889 .............. X = 298,94179894 (this is the DPS before talent modifiers)
This is felguard blizzlike pure weapon DPS before talents and AP contribution: 298,94179894 – 224,7 = 74,24179894 DPS
This is at lvl 70, I do not know if his weapon DPS does change with lvl. The current pure weapon damage at level 70 has 35 DPS and that makes Felguard spec completely broken. According to one wowhead post he should do 200+ hits at lvl 60 therefore I suposse that his weapon DPS does not really change with level:
on 2006/12/29 (Patch 2.0.1) "my fel guard hits for 200+ dmg per swing at lvl 60 not including any spells"
74,24179894 DPS + 224,7 DPS = 298,94179894 + 20% + 5 % + 5% = 395,5 DPS as shown in the picture. After this fix the damage should be just as described in wowhead posts.
Here is a screen of my lock and pet buffed with improved drood mark and shadow resist just like on the retail screen.
the 4points of racial resits are transfered too btw, so i think we're good about resists
Sunday Jul 05, 2015 at 05:42 GMT
Originally opened as https://github.com/ccshiro/cc-buglist/issues/847
Every single private server has to find their way around pet scaling. At first I thought that the goal of having them completely blizzlike may be impossible. But then I did deep research.
I have tested following rules which should apply to each pet:
So far all numbers were correct. However, the tricky part is that all the pets actually scale differently. They dont scale like players – 1 stamina equals 10 hp. They have different scaling factors, thats why voidwalker gets more hp from stamina, they are balanced around those factors which are, unfortunately, secret to us and most private servers usually just try to make up their own scaling factors and base statistics of the pets.
I focused on fellhunter which is the most important pet for PvP. In these videos you can see hp and mana of a fellhunter and also warlocks stamina and intellect.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aDGtKZ-xRuo 0:27
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fmVkJTmKiFE 0:26
I compared those numbers to corecraft. I had the same spec, almost the same amount of stamina and intellect (+/- 1) and the numbers were different: First example: My felhunter had 5845 hp instead of 6127 as shown in the first video.
I found out that corecraft uses these scaling factors: 9 HP per 1 point of stamina and 11 mana per 1 point of intellect for fellhunter. They are obviously wrong.
Following calculations are done with all talent modifiers: Pet stamina with naked warlock = 353 and that is 3595 hp on corecraft 353 * 9 = 3177 hp from stamina. Therefore 3595 – 3177 = 418 (probably HP fellhunter has with 0 stamina ?? ) Naked lvl70 UD warlock 88 stamina – (88 0,3) \ 1,15 = 30,36 stamina for pet =´273,24 hp Pet basic stamina = 322,64 = 2903,76 hp 2903,76 + 418 = 3321,76 HP which pet has on his own Warlock with 813 stamina – pet gains 2250 HP from his gear on CC 3321,76 + 2250 + 273,24 = 5845 total HP
So now I have to find basic HP of fellhunter which he theoretically has without warlock and correct scaling factor of his stamina so that it would match data from both retail server videos. According to the first video he should have 6127 HP with warlocks 813 stamina. And from second video he should have 4702 HP while warlock has just 377 stamina.
Simple linear equations: [(813 * 0,3) * 1,15] x = 6127 – y [(377 * 0,3) * 1,15] x = 4702 – y To make it shorter, X = 9,4734742721 – this is the stamina factor scaling Y = 3469,8325688 this is HP without warlock – so it is more than on corecraft Pet gains a little bit more HP from warlocks gear
Fellhunter would have on retail in S4 gear around 400 hp more than on CC...... So to sum up, completely Blizzlike Fellhunter HP scaling mechanic before warlock stamina and talents would be as follows:
BASIC STAMINA without any contribution of warlock stats (even naked warlock stats) should stay the same as it is so that this change doesnt mess up with Demonic Knowledge talent: 280,1261052606596 stamina BASIC HEALTH of fellhunter with 0 stamina: 418 SCALING FACTOR OF STAMINA: 9,4734742721 HP per 1 point of stamina
I did exactly the same for Mana and the results are: BASIC INTELLECT before warlock and talents: 131 intellect BASIC MANA: 905 SCALING FACTOR OF INTELLECT: 11,506368028 mana per 1 intellect point
Now lets check it out with talent modifiers and compare it with video:
For HP: 418 + [(280,1261052606596 * 1,15) * 9,4734742721] + [(813 * 0,3 * 1,15) * 9,4734742721] = 6127,000000009969
418 + [(280,1261052606596 * 1,15) * 9,4734742721] + [(377 * 0,3 * 1,15) * 9,4734742721] = 4702,000000000687
For Mana: 905 + [(131 * 1,15) * 11,506368028] + [(375 * 0,3 * 1,15) * 11,506368028] = 4127,0707070407 as it can be seen in the first video
I could do the same thing for other pets but I need videos with alike information and that would be much harder to find. Also Felguard is horribly bugged, his dmg is way too low, I will have a look at him and post into this topic asap.