search

netmod-wg / yang-next

Feature requests for future versions of YANG
6 stars 0 forks source link

Clarify whether revision-dates must be unique or not #111

Open rgwilton opened 3 years ago

rgwilton commented 3 years ago

RFC 7950 does not explicitly state whether two different revisions of a module can be published with the same date.

There is an example of an OpenConfig YANG module that has published multiple revisions with the same revision date, and the OpenConfig proponents state that RFC 7950 does not disallow this.

Note - this issue was discussed in the context of YANG versioning, with the question as to whether the YANG Module versioning draft should explicitly require revision dates to be unique, but amongst the authors the thought was that this is out of scope and it would be more appropriate for this to be clarified via an update to RFC 7950.

Either way, it seems like it would be useful if the next revision of YANG is explicit on this.

jsterne commented 2 years ago

Seems to be related to Issue #99

abierman commented 2 months ago

Need to allow. If semver is mandatory then values MUST NOT be the same. This is how openconfig uses duplicate revision dates.

See #99 comments.

BalazsLengyel commented 1 month ago

Clarify whether revision-dates must be unique !!! Critical as it is used to identify the exact version of the module.