This implies that a user with expired credentials can still login.
The bug can be verified easily by creating a new user account, expiring it with chage -E0 username and then trying to log in with the expired credentials.
Remediation
This can be fixed by invoking a call to pam.AcctMgmt after a successful call to pam.Authenticate
Common Vulnerability Scoring System Vector
Exploitability
The attack can be carried over the network. A complex non-standard configuration or a specialized condition is required for the attack to be successfully conducted. The attacker also requires access to a users credentials, be it expired, for an attack to be successful. There is no user interaction required for successful execution. The attack can affect components outside the scope of the target module.
Impact
Using this attack vector, an attacker may access otherwise restricted parts of the system. The attack can be used to gain access to confidential files like passwords, login credentials and other secrets. Hence, it has a high impact on confidentiality. It may also be directly used to affect a change on a system resource. Hence has a medium to high impact on integrity. This attack may not be used to affect the availability of the system. Taking this account an appropriate CVSS v3.1 vector would be
Authorization Bypass due to incorrect usage of PAM library
Not using
pam_acct_mgmtafterpam_authenticateto check the validity of a login can lead to an authorization bypassCommon Weakness Enumeration(CWE) category
CWE - 863
Root Cause Analysis
In this case, in the following PAM transaction, only a call to
pam.Authenticateis used to login a user.https://lgtm.com/projects/g/netsec-ethz/scion-apps/snapshot/52ffbbafc507ba067d56eb9ec482b41c19fc84ed/files/ssh/server/ssh/authcallbacks.go#xecf1a4150da8e10d:1
This implies that a user with expired credentials can still login.
The bug can be verified easily by creating a new user account, expiring it with
chage -E0and then trying to log in with the expired credentials.usernameRemediation
This can be fixed by invoking a call to
pam.AcctMgmtafter a successful call topam.AuthenticateCommon Vulnerability Scoring System Vector
Exploitability
The attack can be carried over the network. A complex non-standard configuration or a specialized condition is required for the attack to be successfully conducted. The attacker also requires access to a users credentials, be it expired, for an attack to be successful. There is no user interaction required for successful execution. The attack can affect components outside the scope of the target module.
Impact
Using this attack vector, an attacker may access otherwise restricted parts of the system. The attack can be used to gain access to confidential files like passwords, login credentials and other secrets. Hence, it has a high impact on confidentiality. It may also be directly used to affect a change on a system resource. Hence has a medium to high impact on integrity. This attack may not be used to affect the availability of the system. Taking this account an appropriate CVSS v3.1 vector would be
(AV:N/AC:H/PR:L/UI:N/S:C/C:H/I:L/A:N)[https://nvd.nist.gov/vuln-metrics/cvss/v3-calculator?vector=AV:N/AC:L/PR:N/UI:N/S:C/C:H/I:N/A:L&version=3.1]
This gives it a base score of 7.7/10 and a severity rating of high.
References
This bug was found using CodeQL by Github