EPIC: Getting token holder information from neume data

djfnd commented 2 years ago

Description An imminent requirement from musicOS will be to retrieve the wallet address that is the current holder of a music NFT. A push goal would be to have a history (by block?) of when the owner of a music NFT has changed and a timeline of who the token was owned by at each time.

Core Requirements

For every music NFT that is indexed into the neume database
Return the current wallet address that holds the NFT
Served in a list, ideally as part of the neume database dump

Additional Requirements

For every music NFT that is indexed into the neume database
Return the current and past wallet addresses that have held the NFT
With the block number that transfer occured
Served in a list, ideally as part of the neume database dump

Challenges

Where NFTs have been sold as editions, there will likely be issues around how to show all holders
A suggestion would be to return all addresses against each music NFT, so that platforms can resolve at the user interface level

vaughnmck commented 2 years ago

We still need to get consensus with the rest of the team and validate with users, but I'm making a note here that we should include both the full list of holders and the original minter, i.e. the artist

We have examples of artists already recreating their catalog using musicOS so there's probably more validation that this is a useful feature.

djfnd commented 2 years ago

We still need to get consensus with the rest of the team and validate with users, but I'm making a note here that we should include both the full list of holders and the original minter, i.e. the artist

We have examples of artists already recreating their catalog using musicOS so there's probably more validation that this is a useful feature.

Good clarification, yes agreed.

And agreed on the validation point, though think that we have enough support to spend the time thinking through how we should do this. It will be a very useful point of utility from neume.

TimDaub commented 2 years ago

First to solve from this issue is: https://github.com/neume-network/schema/issues/52

TimDaub commented 2 years ago

https://github.com/neume-network/strategies/issues/342

neume-network / strategies

EPIC: Getting token holder information from neume data #321