newrelic / newrelic-php-agent

The New Relic PHP Agent
https://opensource.newrelic.com/projects/newrelic/newrelic-php-agent
Apache License 2.0
118 stars 61 forks source link

Is there any plans to add support for ZTS again now when Frankenphp is gaining popularity in Laravel community #864

Open cyppe opened 5 months ago

cyppe commented 5 months ago

I just migrated to Frankenphp as many in the Laravel community is doing now and it will only grow as it now has first party support by Laravel, even though it's still in beta. But it's the most performant combo.

And it uses a ZTS compiled version of php and according to the creator is has use that.

So therefor I'm asking if you can reconsider the dropping of ZTS support and making it supported again? As it will be a bottleneck for a lot of Laravel users moving forward so they cannot continue to use New Relic as a service, and we are one of them.

RubenKruiswijk commented 5 months ago

This also applies to Symfony users as their default docker setup also changed to Frankenphp.

Frankenphp is currently incompatible with ZTS and thus by NewRelic.

I do see an issue being closed where one asked for ZTS: https://github.com/newrelic/newrelic-php-agent/issues/233. The questions asked in that issue were not answered. Instead, it was refered to https://docs.newrelic.com/docs/release-notes/agent-release-notes/php-release-notes/php-agent-10-5-0-317/

I cannot find resources explaining why ZTS was removed. The maintainer of Frankenphp did explain why ZTS is a requirement for FrankenPHP

What do we need to get a ZTS build? Or is there a technical reason why it cannot be created anymore? In that case one have to choose for FrankenPHP XOR NewRelic.

eman1986 commented 3 months ago

I'm also curious why New Relic dropped support for ZTS, nowhere in your docs do you explain why it was dropped. My company is looking to move to frankenphp to benefit from the performance boost it'll give us.

adri commented 3 months ago

Second that, we'd be also interested in using Frankenphp but New Relic is blocking us.

MaikJaek commented 1 week ago

+1 We would also love to try out Frankenphp but are blocked by NewRelic