nextcloud / files_accesscontrol

🚫 App to manage access control for files
https://apps.nextcloud.com/apps/files_accesscontrol
50 stars 21 forks source link

Inconsitent handling of shared folders that is inaccessible #588

Closed mickenordin closed 2 months ago

mickenordin commented 2 months ago

This is similar to #97 but I think behaviour has changed enough to warrant a new report.

Steps to reproduce

  1. Create a tag
  2. Create a flow that denies access to the tag (but perhaps not to yourself)
  3. Create a folder with said tag
  4. Share the folder with someone

Expected behaviour

Folder is never visible anywhere OR folder is visible and greyed out (and a limited details view is accessible). I think I prefer the latter solution, because then at least user can get some indication that there is some access issue. Having the folder there, but greyed out would solve any other issues with confused clients as well.

Actual behaviour

Folder is visible in dashboard and in "shares" meny in files app, but not visible in the list in the files app

Server configuration

Nextcloud 29 with files_accesscontrol

Below are screenshots from this scenario where ''Admin" shares a folder with "Ordinary User":

Create folder with tag and share it

2024-08-30T16:15:43,925091604+02:00

Create flow to block

2024-08-30T16:16:36,650880916+02:00

User logs in and sees folder

2024-08-30T16:12:07,451974240+02:00

User sees folder in overview but not list

2024-08-30T16:11:47,351516017+02:00

User sees folder in shares, but cannot access details

2024-08-30T16:11:23,402776230+02:00

nickvergessen commented 2 months ago

Duplicate of https://github.com/nextcloud/files_accesscontrol/issues/544 Most important details in https://github.com/nextcloud/files_accesscontrol/issues/544#issuecomment-2296603976