Closed Jerome-Herbinet closed 1 year ago
I think this app is not getting updates or fixes anymore, this is sad.
@nickvergessen can you tell me (confirm or not), as @elhananjair seams to think, that "files_rightclick" is a little abandoned ? Effectively, no more release since 2019, strange ? Can you tell us if this issue has to be moved to another project ?
I don't know about the development. But the app is shipped, so no releases on the github repo, but you can see on the tags that it is still included https://github.com/nextcloud/files_rightclick/tags
@PVince81 @MorrisJobke @juliushaertl @NastuzziSamy @nickvergessen @Jerome-Herbinet I have checked the tags, and nextcloud_bot is adding some translations nothing else, there is no activity on this application from developers, no new features, and no bug fixes which means it's not maintained by nextcloud developers anymore.
Thanks for your answer @elhananjair ; I'm waiting for some mentioned contributors to tell us where the “right click” feature is now developed, in order to move this issue to the right place.
It's here. Just no further development done i guess.
I understand your answer, but I find it difficult to understand.
Either the project is abandoned, which means that in a future version of Nextcloud, we are supposed to have no more contextual menu feature when right-clicking on files and folder, or it is necessarily maintained ... somewhere else, and this is the information I would like to have if it is the case.
Either the project is abandoned, which means that in a future version of Nextcloud, we are supposed to have no more contextual menu feature when right-clicking on files and folder
I did not hear of a plan like this.
or it is necessarily maintained
We are a public open source thing. Anyone can try to fix it and help maintaining the app. I guess it does not have enough priority and therefore is not being worked on at the moment by the company, but anyone can try to dive into the bug and try to find the problem and then update the app with a fix? That being said, this app was never maintained by the company, but https://github.com/NastuzziSamy made a nice open source contribution. In the meantime he co-founded another company (judging from the github bio), so might just be out of free time for this.
I understand very well what you are saying, and totally agree with you, being myself a contributor and convinced user of Open Source software 😉
The only thing I would have liked is a clearer indicator like "deprecated", or "no longer maintained", or "now part of the XXX project" ... or even sometimes, "we are looking for volunteer staff to keep the project going".
All this does not in any way distort the spirit of Open Source, and allows everyone to save a little time, or to know what to expect, even if it means investing more time if you have the required skills.
we are looking for volunteer staff to keep the project going
I guess that is it, the question is where to put this and who should.
we are looking for volunteer staff to keep the project going
I guess that is it, the question is where to put this and who should.
The Readme.md should be the right place to indicate the project's health.
@nickvergessen @juliushaertl I just wanted to make it clear that this app is not getting any updates, and in my opinion users must know, however, there is no indication for that just like @Jerome-Herbinet suggested maybe on Readme.md it would be really helpful to at least let the users know.
Feel free to edit the ReadMe, doesn't need anyone from the pinged list to receive even more notifications.
PS sorry for my frustration, just drowning in notifications of things that are not my duty these days
Hi, this PR might fix the bug: https://github.com/nextcloud/files_rightclick/pull/157
⚠️ This issue respects the following points: ⚠️
Bug description
When you right-click on an item placed in the recycle bin, the only choice is "Delete permanently". Already, in this case, something is missing; we should have :
Then, if you select the item (by checking the selection checkbox), it's worse because you find in the contextual menu all the choices you would have if the file was not in the recycle bin:
You should only have the following options:
I also notice that the "Select file range" feature does not work in the recycle bin anyway, so either fix it or remove the select (or multiple select) feature in the recycle bin.
I have seen this on Nextcloud 22, 23 and 24.
Steps to reproduce
Expected behavior
We should have this if no element is selected :
We should have this if one or several element(s) is/are selected :
Note : The "Select file rage" (multiple selection) feature doesn't work in "Deleted files".
Installation method
Web installer on a VPS or web space
Operating system
Debian/Ubuntu
PHP engine version
PHP 8.0
Web server
Apache (supported)
Database engine version
MySQL
Is this bug present after an update or on a fresh install?
Updated from a minor version (ex. 22.2.3 to 22.2.4)
Are you using the Nextcloud Server Encryption module?
Encryption is Disabled
What user-backends are you using?
Configuration report
List of activated Apps
Nextcloud Signing status
Nextcloud Logs
Additional info
No response