search

nextcloud / groupfolders

📁👩‍👩‍👧‍👦 Admin-configured folders shared by everyone in a group. https://github.com/nextcloud-releases/groupfolders
https://apps.nextcloud.com/apps/groupfolders
286 stars 87 forks source link

Supporting ACL permission levels implemented by NC "Secure View" #1199

Open MrTF opened 3 years ago

MrTF commented 3 years ago

Hello

Could it possible to add new permissions to available permission list for group folders and files under them?

For example I need to seperate Download permission from Read permission.

Or I need to add new permission called "Download with Watermark only" which prevents users from downloading without watermark.

Users only with "Download" permission will be able to download without watermark.

How does groupfolders add permission menu? Is it possible to add new permissions to access control list?

fschrempf commented 3 years ago

I think there are two feature requests in this:

  1. Custom user-definable ACL permission types
  2. Adopting "Secure View" features in groupfolders app

For the first one, I don't think this will happen as the number of available permissions (like read, write, share, download, ...) is limited and we either support them or not. Letting the admin create custom one does not make sense to me.

The second request and apparently the reason why you were asking for the first one is to have support for new ACL permission types for the features introduced by NC "Secure View" like, "View only, but no download", or "Download only with watermark". I think this is a valid feature request.

fschrempf commented 3 years ago

There is a similar/related request for "upload only" permissions here: #1723.

SadBoen commented 1 year ago

Three years gone... This is no enough reason to suggest company to use.