nextcloud / polls

🗳️ Polls app for Nextcloud
https://apps.nextcloud.com/apps/polls
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
254 stars 73 forks source link

Sort pools by most "yes-voting" user #2995

Open Coernel82 opened 1 year ago

Coernel82 commented 1 year ago

⚠️ This issue respects the following points: ⚠️

Describe the goal you'd like to achieve

As a poll owner, I want to be able to see which user has the highest "score" in yes and maybe votes, because it helps to find reliable people.

To give an example: I use the date polls for group schedulings - an a capella (singing) ensemble. Naturally I need very high participation. So I polled the whole rest of the year to find the appropriate dates. Some people always have time. Great to work with! Some other people are very unreliable and only have time 10 out of 45 date suggestions. With "sort by reliable" I will not see the best date options but the "best" people with highest availability. So this would fit into the <div class="vote_menu">

This as a result makes it easier to kick out the wrong guys of the team.

Of course via calc / excel export this can be achieved easily! So this is just a nice to have!

Thank you for your great work! Your polls app has evolved over the last years a lot! Who needs doodle???

Describe possible solutions

No response

Additional context

No response

dartcafe commented 1 year ago

Leeds me to some questions:

It is not very complicated, to calculate the voters based on their yes/maybe votes. But I rather think about listing them in descending order in a simpe list.

Think it as a button or menu entry, which opens a modal with a simple list. i.e.

The list will judge yes over maybe, so 13 yes and 3 maybe are ranked lower than 14 yes an 0 maybe.

Coernel82 commented 1 year ago

It is not relevant to sort the users in the fancy graphical way as the other sorting options. I also thought of a modal!

Judging yes over maybe is a philosophic question. For many users and for the commercial doodle the maybe option means "yes, if no other option". For me thinking about the value of a "yes" and a "maybe" I have two states of mind: A "maybe" could be interpreted as a "yes" however a "maybe" also shows that the person might me complicated. So I guess your option of "yes" outranking "maybe" is the best solution!

radoeka commented 1 year ago

Just an idea: would it possible to extent the sort functionality (Ranked order/Date order) with:

Perhaps add a ranking in which yes counts for 2 points and maybe for 1 point?

It's then up to the organizer to use the sort option he/she likes the most.

dartcafe commented 1 year ago

@radoeka This is a total different story and belongs to its own issue. Feel free to add a new feature request, but it should have a good user story, which states a high value.

wargreen commented 10 months ago

I search for same thing. Maybe a little array with only the stats (yes/maybe/no), with sort option, displayed in a tab of sidebar ?

For poll with many answers, it could be a good summary for know what is the best choice. With long text choice and little screen, we need to scroll a lot in both kind of view of the full poll, and sort from head... Not very convenient.

dartcafe commented 10 months ago

You can use the ranked sort to sort the options by rank. Or did I get you wrong?

grafik

wargreen commented 10 months ago

Whooooo ! I didn't know that this switch is more than 2 choice switch (left/right choice). So it is very useful. But for big poll or with lot of text, a summary still needed. Maybe only an export as summary / sorted summary ?