nextcloud / spreed

๐Ÿ—จ๏ธ Nextcloud Talk โ€“ chat, video & audio calls for Nextcloud
https://nextcloud.com/talk
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
1.6k stars 428 forks source link

Use high contrast icons for conversation info #13175

Open marcoambrosini opened 2 weeks ago

marcoambrosini commented 2 weeks ago

Advantages:

Now

Screenshot 2024-08-29 at 11 54 43

Proposed change

Screenshot 2024-08-29 at 11 54 48
marcoambrosini commented 2 weeks ago

Can also be maxcontrast if you think that's too present

Screenshot 2024-08-29 at 11 59 05

Still much better imo

jancborchardt commented 1 week ago

Nice, looks very very clean actually. :) I like it!

AndyScherzinger commented 1 week ago

I like it too ๐Ÿ‘ Bonus points for updating the icon the the Material Symbol for links ๐ŸŽ‰

Antreesy commented 1 week ago

max-contrast fits better here, in my opinion. Shall we schedule it for 31?

ShGKme commented 1 week ago

I'd vote for the old design. It allows to add more text information like the date/time of the last message while keeping icons on the conversation icon.

nickvergessen commented 5 days ago

We also have the "red Camera icon" when a call is on going and I can't see that being inlined, but maybe it could be a "red (blinking?) border" on the avatar.

Also I think the yellow from the favorite should stay somehow, as there is :globe_with_meridians: for federation and :chains: for public there are otherwise quite many icons that try to raise the same importance as my favorites?

jancborchardt commented 5 days ago

We also have the "red Camera icon" when a call is on going and I can't see that being inlined, but maybe it could be a "red (blinking?) border" on the avatar.

@nickvergessen yeah, that sounds good, like a "live" pulsing effect as a nice animation. @marcoambrosini?

Also I think the yellow from the favorite should stay somehow, as there is ๐ŸŒ for federation and โ›“๏ธ for public there are otherwise quite many icons that try to raise the same importance as my favorites?

@nickvergessen agreed as well, also makes it stand out a bit more like favorites should. Needs to be an accessible yellow like in Files @marcoambrosini.

Ivansss commented 5 days ago

We also have the "red Camera icon" when a call is on going and I can't see that being inlined, but maybe it could be a "red (blinking?) border" on the avatar.

@nickvergessen yeah, that sounds good, like a "live" pulsing effect as a nice animation. @marcoambrosini?

What about using a green pulsing effect instead of a red one? Since the user will see a green join call button when entering that conversation, I think green will fit better. We might use a red pulse only when the call is being recorded? (that might be overthinking and it might not be self-explainatory enough)

jancborchardt commented 5 days ago

What about using a green pulsing effect instead of a red one? Since the user will see a green join call button when entering that conversation, I think green will fit better. We might use a red pulse only when the call is being recorded? (that might be overthinking and it might not be self-explainatory enough)

A red dot, or red pulsing is always color code to communicate that something is "Live", which a call is. I donโ€™t think we should do any custom color coding like green here. If the conversation is recorded, people need to accept it in the modal, and there it's properly explained.

marcoambrosini commented 4 days ago

This accessible yellow is so dim and sad that I would prefer if we just used gray for the icon.

Screenshot 2024-09-11 at 15 11 44
nickvergessen commented 4 days ago

We can make it much more yellow with AA and use the brown for AAA as discussed somewhere another day.

marcoambrosini commented 4 days ago

The color above is barely 3:1 (AA) with our rather bright background on this navigation. I don't see how we can meet the requirements with a brighter color. Could you or someone that was in that discussion provide source or docs about this?

jancborchardt commented 4 days ago

@marcoambrosini accessible yellow aka dark orange / gold is still better than grey among other icons for a star thatโ€™s supposed to stand out. :)