search

nextcloud / spreed

πŸ—¨οΈ Nextcloud Talk – chat, video & audio calls for Nextcloud
https://nextcloud.com/talk
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
1.6k stars 426 forks source link

Edit chat messages #1836

Closed sunjam closed 5 months ago

sunjam commented 5 years ago

How to use GitHub

Related to #774, but a different feature request. I'd like the ability to edit my chat messages in Talk. This is a common practice when dealing with typos, etc. and an expectation of common users.

Thanks for reading, and thanks for all your great work!

alauzon commented 1 year ago

Exactly, there are messages which tell them "hey delete the message with ID x" and for edit we basically need "hey refresh the content of the message with ID x"

Do you have the link to the Δ₯one app(s) ticket(s) for the delete function?

nickvergessen commented 1 year ago

Couldn't find an iOS link, Android is here: https://github.com/nextcloud/talk-android/pull/985

escii commented 12 months ago

please make it possible for admins do edit or at least delete messages when every they have to.. also moving messages from one channel to another would be very handy.

alauzon commented 12 months ago

Are there people willing to pay me in order to do that? And how can we arrange that? I think that there are tools to help raise money for features, right?

warnerbryce commented 11 months ago

@alauzon i could give you a tip like 100€ but i can't afford more. tell me if you are interested and where i can tip you

christiansass commented 10 months ago

Add me to the waiting list... I'm also trying to see if we can contribute any resources to this issue.

jdaviescoates commented 10 months ago

Signal recently got editing and it's so much better now. I can't wait for Nextcloud Talk to join the "able to edit messages" club too!

Folaht commented 10 months ago

Same here.

mophilly commented 10 months ago

Also, there's been a suggestion that the ability to edit the message should expire after 15 minutes to keep resources down. Any thoughts?

It seems to me that is a feature needed when the message volume becomes quite high and impacts the server load. First step is to get a basic edit function in place and well tested.

mophilly commented 10 months ago

Are there people willing to pay me in order to do that? And how can we arrange that? I think that there are tools to help raise money for features, right?

I can contribute a small amount, too. I may be able to assist with some testing.

Please add me to the waiting list

iwex commented 9 months ago

Also need this feature

nickvergessen commented 9 months ago

Because we don't need further bagging for this feature at the moment, I will lock this ticket. It's on our radar and might be included in the future, but unless someone can implement it on iOS, Android, WebFrontend and the API level, it will have to wait.

Pointers were given above already:

nickvergessen commented 9 months ago

I'm unlocking this due to the comment in #10833 I also edited the default feature enhancement template into the first post which was missing because it did not exist back then:

How to use GitHub

If you are a developer of either platform you can still and surely reach out to get involved in implementing this feature, see above comment for hints on the delete feature which should give a first blue print how it should work.

You could also reach out to help implementing any other feature which then in return frees time to look into things like this feature here which require coordination across all clients.

ChildLearningClub commented 6 months ago

Hi, just a thought, but couldn't this be easily piggybacked on the work that has already been done with the delete and copy message functionalities? The "Edit message" option could run the copy message function -> then the "Delete" -> and replace the "Message deleted by you" by the pasted text from copy. Some code would need to be added " if Edit message pressed: enable "send message" again logic. I realize that the "Copy formatted message" is a system copy to clipboard so that would also need to be adjusted.

Anyway, just throwing that out as an idea. May be total nonsense, but i guess if it gets someone thinking then it is worth the post :).

nickvergessen commented 5 months ago

Closed via https://github.com/nextcloud/spreed/issues/11203

szaimen commented 5 months ago

πŸŽ‰πŸŽ‰πŸŽ‰πŸŽ‰πŸŽ‰