nextdns / metadata

This repository contains the data behind our Security, Privacy and Parental Control features.
https://nextdns.io
638 stars 138 forks source link

hopp.to is blocked by Threat Intelligence Feeds #1209

Closed shaulgo closed 1 year ago

shaulgo commented 1 year ago

Hey, Hopp.to is blocked by Threat Intelligence Feeds. It is a link shortener and link-in-bio product by wix.com. Can you whitelist the domain? Like any link shortener, subdomains should be blocked individually. Thanks

romaincointepas commented 1 year ago

Could you please suggest it directly to https://github.com/PeterDaveHello/url-shorteners?

shaulgo commented 1 year ago

Thanks, I will do that :)

shaulgo commented 1 year ago

I had a long conversation with @PeterDaveHello (https://github.com/PeterDaveHello/url-shorteners/pull/23). Unfortunately we are not a good fit for his list. His list is only for services that allow to change the path. Where we also change the subdomain.

Hopp.to is a legitimate link shortener and link-in-bio (owned by wix.com).

The url structure of the services is provided like so:

  1. [username].hopp.to/[custom]
  2. hopp.to/[username]

So the parent domain should be handled separately from subdomains and paths. Could you please whitelist us? Also, are you using a blocklist? I connected all the lists I could find and they all removed us from their blocklist and added us to their white list (if they have one).

Thanks, Shaul

PeterDaveHello commented 1 year ago

One approach in https://github.com/PeterDaveHello/url-shorteners may be to list those parent domains for the use cases like hopp.to, but still need NextDNS to make sure their subdomains will be whitelisted. I would be curious about the priority when there are parent domains and different subdomains in both blacklist and whitelist, who has the highest priority to be applied?

shaulgo commented 1 year ago

@romaincointepas do you know why hopp.to is still blocked? This is very frustrating. It's been removed from every block list and service I can find.

Except 1 one that is marked in Phishtank. Phishtank doesn't have a way to contact them. While the path has been deleted a long time ago.