search

nfarina / homebridge-tesla

Tesla plugin for homebridge: https://github.com/nfarina/homebridge
154 stars 38 forks source link

Lock Command opens Trunk #73

Closed sdorilas closed 2 years ago

sdorilas commented 3 years ago

Hello there,

New user, recently installed. Plug-in is working exactly as expected, with one exception. Whenever I tell Siri “Lock my Model Y doors”. She will lock the doors but she will also open the Trunk. Is this a config issue?

nfarina commented 2 years ago

That is super strange, I haven't seen this before. Is it still happening?

JBake130 commented 2 years ago

Just installed and only see one “switch” unlock, which opens my trunk as well

krinderknecht commented 2 years ago

Same. Also Model Y. Unlocking opens the trunk and frunk. Locking opens the trunk. :(

kkissane0328 commented 2 years ago

New user, same issue here

johnschult commented 2 years ago

Same issue with my Model Y

luke2m commented 2 years ago

This is slightly different, here (Model Y) the trunk and frunk open when asking "unlock the model y doors".

I think this is because Siri is recognizing anything configured as a lock as on a door, so it is opening all of them. A workaround I have found is renaming "doors" to "car doors". @nfarina It seems like if there could be a config option to present the frunk and trunk as a switch rather than a lock, as there is with Sentry mode, this could be solved.

nfarina commented 2 years ago

yeah I've been having this problem as well, not sure how to best remedy. I think renaming "doors" to "car doors" is a good interim solution.

Changing the trunk+frunk to be switches would mean that you would have to say "Turn on the trunk" which is a bit awkward.

nfarina commented 2 years ago

OK I tried it and can confirm renaming to "car doors" makes everything work as expected. I'm going to ship this change as a bug fix to get it out there.

Happy to revisit if anyone has a better idea for optimizing voice commands here!