search

ngscopeclient / scopehal-apps

ngscopeclient and other client applications for libscopehal.
https://www.ngscopeclient.org/
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
616 stars 104 forks source link

Rigol DS1054Z Socket read failed #790

Closed krekr closed 2 weeks ago

krekr commented 3 weeks ago

I'm running ngscopeclient 0.1-dev+c6a7d4d3 on a clean Ubuntu 24.04.1 LTS install, which works fine with the 'demo' oscilloscope. When I try to connect it to my Rigol scope, it says: Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable).

I can tell the program interacts with the scope, which periodically says Invalid input! on screen. The app will also sometimes freezes so long the Ubuntu taskmanager intervenes, showing ngscopeclient 0.1-dev+c6a7d4d3 is not respond...

Also, when trying to set the sample rate, this is printed to the terminal: ERROR: RigolOscilloscope::GetInterleaveConflicts not implemented for this model

From the manual (and various posts on social media) I got the impression that the Rigol DS1000-range was considered stable. Am I missing something or is this a bug?

azonenberg commented 3 weeks ago

The GetInterleaveConflicts message probably means that the driver doesn't know what scope model it's talking to and is completely confused.

How are you connecting to the scope (USB, Ethernet, etc)? What's the exact connection path you're providing?

Try running ngscopeclient with --debug --trace SCPISocketTransport (assuming you're connecting via Ethernet) and upload the resulting console output.

krekr commented 3 weeks ago

It's connected over Ethernet: the path is 192.168.1.17:5555. Transport is lan.

OMP_WAIT_POLICY not set to PASSIVE
Re-exec'ing with correct environment
Initializing Vulkan
    VK_KHR_get_physical_device_properties2: supported
    VK_KHR_xcb_surface: supported
    VK_KHR_xlib_surface: supported
    VK_EXT_debug_utils: supported
    Loader/API support available for Vulkan 1.3
    Vulkan 1.2 support available, requesting it
    Initializing glfw 3.3.10 X11 GLX EGL OSMesa clock_gettime evdev shared
    GLFW required extensions:
        VK_KHR_surface
        VK_KHR_xcb_surface
    Physical devices:
        Device 0: llvmpipe (LLVM 17.0.6, 128 bits)
            API version:            0x00403112 (0.1.3.274)
            Driver version:         0x00000001 (0.0.0.1)
            Vendor ID:              10005
            Device ID:              0000
            Device type:            CPU
            int64:                  yes
            int16:                  yes (allowed in SSBOs)
            int8:                   yes (allowed in SSBOs)
            Max image dim 2D:       16384
            Max storage buf range:  128 MB
            Max mem objects:        4294967295
            Max compute shared mem: 32 KB
            Max compute grp count:  65535 x 65535 x 65535
            Max compute invocs:     1024
            Max compute grp size:   1024 x 1024 x 1024
            Memory types:
                Type 0
                    Heap index: 0
                    Device local
                    Host visible
                    Host coherent
                    Host cached
            Memory heaps:
                Heap 0
                    Size: 3 GB
                    Device local
        Selected device 0
            Queue families (1 total)
                Queue type 0
                    Queue count:          1
                    Timestamp valid bits: 64
                    Graphics
                    Compute
                    Transfer
            Driver: vk::DriverId::eMesaLlvmpipe
            Enabling 64-bit float support
            Enabling 64-bit integer support
            Enabling 16-bit integer support
            Enabling 16-bit integer support for SSBOs
            Enabling 8-bit integer support
            Enabling 8-bit integer support for SSBOs
            Device has VK_KHR_push_descriptor, requesting it
            Device has VK_KHR_shader_non_semantic_info, requesting it
            Device has VK_EXT_memory_budget, requesting it
            Device has VK_EXT_shader_atomic_float, requesting it
            Using heap 0, type 0 for pinned host memory
            Using heap 0, type 0 for card-local memory
            Unified memory GPU optimizations are enabled
            Sorted queues:
                Family=0 Index=0 Flags=00000007
            QueueManager creating family=0 index=0 name=g_vkTransferQueue

    vkFFT version: 1.3.3
Detecting CPU features...

Using ImGui version 1.91.4
Vulkan driver is Mesa.
Disabling vkSetDebugUtilsObjectNameEXT on VkSurfaceKHR objects to work around driver bug.
Unable to open recently used files list (bad file)
Connecting to SCPI device at 192.168.1.17:5555
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending *IDN?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :WAV:FORM BYTE
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :WAV:MODE RAW
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TIM:VERN ON
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending :CHAN1:DISP?
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending :CHAN2:DISP?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending :CHAN3:DISP?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending :CHAN4:DISP?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :CHAN1:DISP ON
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :CHAN1:DISP?
Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:MODE?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:EDGE:SOUR?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:EDGE:LEV?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:EDGE:SLOPE?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TIM:MAIN:OFFS?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :ACQ:SRAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :ACQ:MDEP?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :CHAN1:OFFS?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :CHAN1:RANGE?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :SING
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending *WAI
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:SOUR CHAN1
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:PRE?
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 1
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 250000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 250001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 500000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 500001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 750000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
azonenberg commented 3 weeks ago

So the driver is sending a bunch of commands to the scope and it's getting no replies whatesoever. This isn't looking like a problem on the ngscopeclient side so far.

Have you tried rebooting the scope? If you netcat to the SCPI port on the scope and send *IDN? and a newline, do you get anything back?

krekr commented 3 weeks ago

Thanks for the quick replies, that sounds reasonable. I'll try tomorrow!

azonenberg commented 3 weeks ago

Actually, that may not be correct. It looks like we may actually have a bug in logging of command responses due to some recent refactoring. Give me a bit to poke at this on my end.

azonenberg commented 3 weeks ago

Ok confirmed, there was a logging bug. Please update to f4ad90df3 (make sure to pull submodules recursively) and repeat the trace.

krekr commented 3 weeks ago

Interesting. I'll try that later. Regarding the netcat question:

gregor@krekrm2 ~ % nc 192.168.1.17 5555 
*IDN?
RIGOL TECHNOLOGIES,DS1104Z,DS1ZA170301256,00.04.02.SP4

reply is pretty instantaneous as well. However; I do see weird behaviour with other utilities, e.g. scopesnap (here) and this script as well. First I took that as buggy programs, but now three programs in a row fail to connect to my scope!? Is there any option that needs to be set for e.g. ngscopeclient to work (LXI-related or smth?). Everything is on the same LAN, no switches or routers in between etc. Scope is performing fine otherwise, has connected to Ultrasigma etc. over LAN in the past as well.

azonenberg commented 3 weeks ago

We are not using LXI, raw SCPI tends to perform better when available.

Try re-running the trace with the latest version, you probably will get replies, but then something else is going wrong.

krekr commented 3 weeks ago

It's building now. Oh - forgot to note it's running inside a Virtualbox VM (win 10 host) and there are several warnings during compilation, e.g.;

/home/krekr/scopehal-apps/lib/scopehal/FlowGraphNode.cpp: In member function ‘virtual void FlowGraphNode::Refresh(vk::raii::CommandBuffer&, std::shared_ptr<QueueHandle>)’:
/home/krekr/scopehal-apps/lib/scopehal/FlowGraphNode.cpp:98:16: warning: ‘virtual void FlowGraphNode::Refresh()’ is deprecated [-Wdeprecated-declarations]
   98 |         Refresh();
      |         ~~~~~~~^~
/home/krekr/scopehal-apps/lib/scopehal/FlowGraphNode.cpp:87:6: note: declared here
   87 | void FlowGraphNode::Refresh()
      |      ^~~~~~~~~~~~~
azonenberg commented 3 weeks ago

Yep, that's a reminder to us that some legacy functions haven't been fully removed. It's expected and harmless, we're gonna refactor the rest of it out at some point but likely not in time for the v0.1 release EOY.

krekr commented 3 weeks ago

I'm not too familiar with git so I just pulled the latest version (af3f7267), assuming the same change is in there. It seems to startup faster. Now I'm getting;

krekr@ubuntu:~/scopehal-apps/build/src/ngscopeclient$ ./ngscopeclient --debug --trace SCPISocketTransport
OMP_WAIT_POLICY not set to PASSIVE
Re-exec'ing with correct environment
Initializing Vulkan
    VK_KHR_get_physical_device_properties2: supported
    VK_KHR_xcb_surface: supported
    VK_KHR_xlib_surface: supported
    VK_EXT_debug_utils: supported
    Loader/API support available for Vulkan 1.3
    Vulkan 1.2 support available, requesting it
    Initializing glfw 3.3.10 X11 GLX EGL OSMesa clock_gettime evdev shared
    GLFW required extensions:
        VK_KHR_surface
        VK_KHR_xcb_surface
    Physical devices:
        Device 0: llvmpipe (LLVM 17.0.6, 128 bits)
            API version:            0x00403112 (0.1.3.274)
            Driver version:         0x00000001 (0.0.0.1)
            Vendor ID:              10005
            Device ID:              0000
            Device type:            CPU
            int64:                  yes
            int16:                  yes (allowed in SSBOs)
            int8:                   yes (allowed in SSBOs)
            Max image dim 2D:       16384
            Max storage buf range:  128 MB
            Max mem objects:        4294967295
            Max compute shared mem: 32 KB
            Max compute grp count:  65535 x 65535 x 65535
            Max compute invocs:     1024
            Max compute grp size:   1024 x 1024 x 1024
            Memory types:
                Type 0
                    Heap index: 0
                    Device local
                    Host visible
                    Host coherent
                    Host cached
            Memory heaps:
                Heap 0
                    Size: 3 GB
                    Device local
        Selected device 0
            Queue families (1 total)
                Queue type 0
                    Queue count:          1
                    Timestamp valid bits: 64
                    Graphics
                    Compute
                    Transfer
            Driver: vk::DriverId::eMesaLlvmpipe
            Enabling 64-bit float support
            Enabling 64-bit integer support
            Enabling 16-bit integer support
            Enabling 16-bit integer support for SSBOs
            Enabling 8-bit integer support
            Enabling 8-bit integer support for SSBOs
            Device has VK_KHR_push_descriptor, requesting it
            Device has VK_KHR_shader_non_semantic_info, requesting it
            Device has VK_EXT_memory_budget, requesting it
            Device has VK_EXT_shader_atomic_float, requesting it
            Using heap 0, type 0 for pinned host memory
            Using heap 0, type 0 for card-local memory
            Unified memory GPU optimizations are enabled
            Sorted queues:
                Family=0 Index=0 Flags=00000007
            QueueManager creating family=0 index=0 name=g_vkTransferQueue

    vkFFT version: 1.3.3
Detecting CPU features...

Using ImGui version 1.91.4
Vulkan driver is Mesa.
Disabling vkSetDebugUtilsObjectNameEXT on VkSurfaceKHR objects to work around driver bug.
Unable to open recently used files list (bad file)
Connecting to SCPI device at 192.168.1.17:5555
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending *IDN?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got RIGOL TECHNOLOGIES,DS1104Z,DS1ZA170301256,00.04.02.SP4
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :WAV:FORM BYTE
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :WAV:MODE RAW
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TIM:VERN ON
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending :CHAN1:DISP?
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply]     [192.168.1.17] Got command error
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending :CHAN2:DISP?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply]     [192.168.1.17] Got 0
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending :CHAN3:DISP?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply]     [192.168.1.17] Got 0
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending :CHAN4:DISP?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply]     [192.168.1.17] Got 0
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :CHAN1:DISP ON
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:MODE?
Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got command error
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
Warning: Unknown trigger type "command error"
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:EDGE:SOUR?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got CHAN1
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:EDGE:LEV?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got 2.040000e+00
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:EDGE:SLOPE?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got NEG
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TIM:MAIN:OFFS?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got 1.6500000e-04
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :ACQ:SRAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got 1.000000e+09
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :ACQ:MDEP?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :CHAN1:OFFS?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got 0.000000e+00
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :CHAN1:RANGE?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got 1.600000e+01
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :CHAN1:DISP?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got 1
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got AUTO
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :STOP
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :TRIG:STAT?
Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadReply] [192.168.1.17] Got command error
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand] [192.168.1.17] Sending :STOP

...

[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 250001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 500000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read timed out
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 500001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 750000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read timed out
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 750001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 1000000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read timed out
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 1000001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 1250000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read timed out
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 1250001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 1500000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read timed out
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 1500001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 1750000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read timed out
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 1750001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 2000000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read timed out
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 2000001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 2250000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read timed out
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 2250001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 2500000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read timed out
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 2500001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 2750000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read timed out
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 2750001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 3000000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read timed out
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 3000001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 3250000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read timed out
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 3250001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 3500000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read timed out
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 3500001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 3750000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read timed out
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 3750001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 4000000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read timed out
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 4000001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 4250000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read timed out
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 4250001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 4500000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read timed out
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 4500001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 4750000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read timed out
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 4750001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 5000000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 5000001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 5250000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 5250001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 5500000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 5500001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 5750000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 250001 bytes (@ pos 0)
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STAR 5750001
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:STOP 6000000
[SCPISocketTransport::SendCommand]     [192.168.1.17] Sending WAV:DATA?
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Got 2 bytes
    Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable)
[SCPISocketTransport::ReadRawData]     Failed to get 12 bytes (@ pos 0)
Killed

Which doesn't seem all that different (still no scope image). It's also hanging again sometimes.

krekr commented 3 weeks ago

Ok, I'm a step further. I thought I'd update the 'scope firmware since that was a while ago. It was running 00.04.02.SP4, now the latest available version 00.04.05.02.xx. I didn't get the Warning: Socket read failed (errno=11, Resource temporarily unavailable), but also no waveform. This might be because the scope doesn't show anything until it's recalibrated after the update (which it is doing now). The screenshot programs now also work. I'll report back after the calibration. Hope I didn't waste your time because of this.

azonenberg commented 3 weeks ago

If the old scope firmware didn't work, that's still valuable information. We can add a note to the documentation and maybe a warning in the driver if we detect the scope is running the buggy version.

krekr commented 3 weeks ago

That's right. It was also 10 years old ;) Calibration failed for some reason. Very excited to try it out tomorrow.

krekr commented 2 weeks ago

Just wanted to let you know it works now. So this seems tied to firmware version indeed. Unfortunately I have no idea which fw versions are buggy and which are not. I hadn't realised how slow 0.1WFM/s is, haha. I'll have to figure out a way to decrease the sample rate/depth; the links for that don't seem to work for Rigol scopes? At least now I feel confident about getting this to compile and run to consider getting a Thunderscope; I've been looking into ngscopeclient since a few years ago...

azonenberg commented 2 weeks ago

Yeah, pretty much all of the entry level scopes are intolerably slow at useful memory depths, which is why I'm so excited about the ThunderScope. Getting 25 WFM/s on 4 channels with 10M points per channel is such a game changer compared to the slow stuff.

Changing sample rate/depth should be doable via setup | timebase or double clicking the timeline (there's a few other ways to get to the same dialog). If the dropdowns are empty or selecting them doesn't change anything on the scope, that's a driver bug and should be reported as a separate ticket against the ngscopeclient/scopehal repository

I added a note about the known problematic firmware to the documentation (https://github.com/ngscopeclient/scopehal-docs/commit/48a4c5a37433c4b9d027aefc6b0a02232c804c05).

Can we close this ticket now?