Closed dbarrosop closed 4 days ago
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review [1-5] | 4 |
๐งช Relevant tests | No |
๐ Security concerns | No |
โก Key issues to review |
Possible Bug: The removal of OpenAPI route setup and related schema definitions could lead to undocumented API endpoints. Ensure that the API documentation is updated or maintained elsewhere if necessary. |
Dependency Check: Ensure that no other parts of the application depend on the removed OpenAPI setup or the removed routes. This includes any front-end components or external systems that might be using these endpoints. | |
Configuration Changes: The removal of environment variables and configurations related to the removed features should be verified to ensure they are no longer needed or referenced elsewhere in the application. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Enhancement |
Add error handling middleware to improve application robustness___ **Consider adding a fallback or error handling middleware for the routes. This can helpmanage errors that are not caught within the route handlers, improving the robustness of the application.** [src/routes/index.ts [28-34]](https://github.com/nhost/hasura-auth/pull/537/files#diff-4c1a276a826a5147689418cdbf9bde24c8326cedb30a61144fe7867bd99113efR28-R34) ```diff router.use(signInRouter); router.use(signOutRouter); router.use(elevateRouter); router.use(userRouter); router.use(mfaRouter); router.use(tokenRouter); router.use(verifyRouter); +router.use(errorHandlingMiddleware); // Add this line ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Adding error handling middleware is a good practice to catch unhandled errors and improve the robustness of the application. This suggestion is contextually accurate and enhances the new code introduced in the PR. | 8 |
Possible issue |
Ensure alternative authentication methods are provided after removing some sign-in methods___ **Since the email-password and passwordless email sign-in methods have been removed, ensurethat there is a clear migration path or alternative authentication methods provided to users to prevent access issues.** [src/routes/signin/index.ts [6-15]](https://github.com/nhost/hasura-auth/pull/537/files#diff-26afd2e4ccfcac5d8a5fdbd1312ac77bfa6d2269f06b7180b4ca75c8d523d642R6-R15) ```diff import { signInAnonymousHandler, signInAnonymousSchema } from './anonymous'; import { signInMfaTotpHandler, signInMfaTotpSchema } from './mfa'; import { signInPasswordlessSmsHandler, signInPasswordlessSmsSchema, } from './passwordless'; import { signInOtpHandler, signInOtpSchema } from './passwordless/sms/otp'; import { signInVerifyWebauthnHandler, signInVerifyWebauthnSchema, } from './webauthn'; +// Consider adding alternative methods here or ensure migration is handled ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion correctly identifies the removal of certain authentication methods and advises ensuring alternative methods or migration paths. This is important for maintaining user access and preventing issues. | 7 |
Re-add or ensure coverage for user email change and verification functionalities___ **It appears that the user email change and send verification email functionalities havebeen removed. If these features are still needed, consider re-adding them or ensuring that their functionality is covered elsewhere in the application.** [src/routes/user/index.ts [7-16]](https://github.com/nhost/hasura-auth/pull/537/files#diff-14d43bc8570c6586d8a64c92ea9fe4ddd2a6fd85db68a8d0de8f7292c1476f36R7-R16) ```diff import { userMFAHandler, userMfaSchema } from './mfa'; import { userHandler } from './user'; import { userPasswordHandler, userPasswordSchema } from './password'; import { userProviderTokensHandler, userProviderTokensSchema, } from './provider-tokens'; import { addSecurityKeyHandler, addSecurityKeyVerifyHandler, } from './security-keys'; +// Re-add or ensure coverage for user email change and verification ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion highlights the removal of important user functionalities and advises ensuring these features are covered elsewhere. This is crucial for user management and maintaining application functionality. | 7 | |
Consider re-adding the token refresh endpoint if still required___ **The removal of the token refresh endpoint could lead to issues with token management. Iftoken refreshing is still required, consider re-adding this endpoint or providing a new mechanism for token management.** [src/routes/token/index.ts [3-7]](https://github.com/nhost/hasura-auth/pull/537/files#diff-c2bb5010a945faf6edfb700cde9fd283e19df6130afda9c2264e83b70267304cR3-R7) ```diff import { asyncWrapper as aw } from '@/utils'; import { bodyValidator } from '@/validation'; import { verifyTokenHandler, verifyTokenSchema } from './verify'; +import { tokenHandler, tokenSchema } from './token'; // Re-add this if needed const router = Router(); ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion correctly points out the potential issues with token management due to the removal of the token refresh endpoint. Re-adding this endpoint or providing an alternative mechanism is important for maintaining secure and efficient token management. | 7 |
PR Type
Enhancement, Other
Description
Changes walkthrough ๐
22 files
app.ts
Remove OpenAPI route and clean up middleware usage
src/app.ts
addOpenApiRoute
.index.ts
Remove OpenAPI route setup and schema definitions
src/openapi/index.ts
definitions.
responses.ts
Remove OpenAPI response models
src/openapi/responses.ts
schemas.
index.ts
Remove PAT and sign-up routes
src/routes/index.ts - Removed imports and usage of `patRouter` and `signUpRouter`.
index.ts
Remove Personal Access Token (PAT) route
src/routes/pat/index.ts
(PAT) route.
pat.ts
Remove PAT handler and schema
src/routes/pat/pat.ts
creating PATs.
email-password.ts
Remove email-password sign-in handler and schema
src/routes/signin/email-password.ts
handler and schema.
index.ts
Remove email-password, PAT, and passwordless email sign-in routes
src/routes/signin/index.ts
email sign-in handlers and schemas.
email.ts
Remove passwordless email sign-in handler and schema
src/routes/signin/passwordless/email.ts
handler and schema.
index.ts
Remove passwordless email sign-in export
src/routes/signin/passwordless/index.ts - Removed export of passwordless email sign-in.
pat.ts
Remove PAT sign-in handler and schema
src/routes/signin/pat.ts
schema.
email-password.ts
Remove email-password sign-up handler and schema
src/routes/signup/email-password.ts
handler and schema.
index.ts
Remove sign-up routes
src/routes/signup/index.ts - Deleted the entire file which contained the sign-up routes.
index.ts
Remove WebAuthn sign-up and verification exports
src/routes/signup/webauthn/index.ts - Removed exports for WebAuthn sign-up and verification.
signup.ts
Remove WebAuthn sign-up handler and schema
src/routes/signup/webauthn/signup.ts
and schema.
verify.ts
Remove WebAuthn sign-up verification handler and schema
src/routes/signup/webauthn/verify.ts
verification handler and schema.
index.ts
Remove token refresh route
src/routes/token/index.ts - Removed import and usage of token refresh handler and schema.
deanonymize.ts
Remove user deanonymize handler and schema
src/routes/user/deanonymize.ts
and schema.
change.ts
Remove user email change handler and schema
src/routes/user/email/change.ts
and schema.
index.ts
Remove user email change and verification exports
src/routes/user/email/index.ts
handlers.
send-verification-email.ts
Remove user email send verification email handler and schema
src/routes/user/email/send-verification-email.ts
verification email handler and schema.
index.ts
Remove user email, password reset, and deanonymize routes
src/routes/user/index.ts
email, password reset, and deanonymize handlers and schemas.