nic-delhi / AarogyaSetu_Android

Aarogya Setu Android app native code
https://www.aarogyasetu.gov.in/
Other
2.89k stars 1.95k forks source link

Use Aadhaar card scanning as login info [Not an issue] #169

Closed custadian closed 4 years ago

custadian commented 4 years ago

Hi There,

I think, people are not giving the correct info while logging in. I advice to scan Aadhaar card and this info will always be correct. Or else, some how the registered mobile no should get info from Aadhaar server(using an API).

One more idea can be here is that our testing kits should have hardware inbuilt and we may buy them from medical shops to test. This kit should only be activated only by app by scanning Aadhaar card. So if someone tests +ve then we have the correct info and officials can track them easily.

-Thanks

chirag-jn commented 4 years ago

The only thing which isn't available with Aadhaar is our location history (not at a granular level), and you are suggesting to expose that too?

custadian commented 4 years ago

@chirag-jn , I am suggesting to use Aadhar to get info instead of user entering that. Regarding the location, anyways if your phone's location is on then only you could be trackable.

HaneetGH commented 4 years ago

Aadhaar actually tells which citizen is using which device and where he is and more info from device..

that can be scary

pikvik commented 4 years ago

Mapping citizen adhaar is te biggest blunder any one wish to , I wonder why that to be even considered

SarangKulkarni commented 4 years ago

Since Aadhar is "optional", as argued in the Supreme Court case, using it as a login instrument will prevent people without Aadhar from gaining access to the ability to protect themselves and result in withholding of valuable information about the COVID status of excluded people from the community. Since it is in public interest that Aarogya Setu be inclusive and be widely adopted, Aadhar should not be used for anything related to Aarogya Setu.

custadian commented 4 years ago

I think better to close this. -Thanks