search

nightscout / AndroidAPS

Opensource automated insulin delivery system (closed loop)
https://wiki.aaps.app
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
694 stars 1.7k forks source link

Progress pop-up windows for manual bolus immediately closed while bolus still progressing #836

Closed vanelsberg closed 2 years ago

vanelsberg commented 2 years ago

AndroidAPS 2.8.2.9-dev Build: aea868ac6 / Fullrelease Pump: DASH

Problem description: When starting a manual bolus (2u) the progress window popped, immediately showed a full bar, then closed. The bollus command itself was executed without problems: seeing progress on wear, Pod ticking, DASH history confirming.

Repro: This was a one-time occasion, could not repro.

Additional Info This very much looks like the problem AAPS had some months ago: The problems then was caused by starting a manual bolus at the moment an SMB was running. When SMB finished it closed the progress window (for the manual bolus)?

MilosKozak commented 2 years ago

this is close to impossible with current implementation

vanelsberg commented 2 years ago

(grin) I'd take your word on that. Problem is that I have seen it happen twice now. So maybe there is some other cause that closes the pop-up. Will check the logs to see if they show anything that is "impossible" ;-)

MilosKozak commented 2 years ago

i did some improvement recently but to be honest i'm not 100% sure it helps

vanelsberg commented 2 years ago

@MilosKozak Tnx. Have not seen it happen for a while as I described. So improvement may have helped here.

One way to repro which may be similar in behavior: Start a manual bolus. Then on the phone switch to active apps view (pressing button on the bottom if the phone screen) and swipe/close AAPS. In will continue the bolus on the background (wear notifications confirm by showing progress). Opening AAPS does no longer show the progress pop-up (while bolus is progressing in the background). Can reproduce this behavior without any problem.

MilosKozak commented 2 years ago

when you close app (by swiping out) all activities are destroyed and there is no way to restore it. it's android design if you switch to another app and back bolus progress survive as activity is restored

vanelsberg commented 2 years ago

@MilosKozak Minor issues but it still is there? Do not think this should have high priority but still seeing this behavior now and then, also for current 3.0 release/dev branch.

Start a manual bolus from overview (so no closing of the app): On starting the bolus progress opens with a flash of 100% yellow progress, then seams to start the bolus (grey 0% progress) immediately (within 1 secs) followed by closing the progress pop-up. Bolus does proceed in the background without issues.

Just can not find a way to reproduce this. Have seen at least 2 users in Discord reporting the same.

CaptainBalou commented 2 years ago

@MilosKozak Minor issues but it still is there? Do not think this should have high priority but still seeing this behavior now and then, also for current 3.0 release/dev branch.

Start a manual bolus from overview (so no closing of the app): On starting the bolus progress opens with a flash of 100% yellow progress, then seams to start the bolus (grey 0% progress) immediately (within 1 secs) followed by closing the progress pop-up. Bolus does proceed in the background without issues.

Just can not find a way to reproduce this. Have seen at least 2 users in Discord reporting the same.

I've had this as well with 3.0 betas. Setup here is DanaRS, Dexcom G6 with BYOD. But because I've found no way to reproduce it I couldn't create a log. Because the bolus in background was always delivered well I haven't put that much energy into it.

TranceCake commented 2 years ago

I have seen this with both 2.8.x and 3.0 about 8+ times I think, of which 3 in 3.0

antoinekh commented 2 years ago

Still same problem in last dev #1315