nishanths / license

Command line license text generator.
MIT License
663 stars 83 forks source link

Missing ISC license #37

Closed ghost closed 2 years ago

ghost commented 2 years ago

The README mentions the ISC license, although as far as I can see it was never supported.

image

I can open a PR to add it, or was there a reason it was removed?

nishanths commented 2 years ago

I don't think there was a conscious decision to remove the license (if it existed before), so +1 for including it. Thanks.

Regarding whether the license existed before:

Originally the license command used to obtain licenses at runtime via the https://api.github.com/licenses API. It may have been that the GitHub API back then returned the isc license, but later stopped doing it. A few years later, the license command was changed to include the available licenses at build time. When this change was made, the licenses were obtained from the current list on the GitHub API, so isc may have been missed at this time.

Or it may be that the license has been missing from the start.

nishanths commented 2 years ago

It may have been that the GitHub API back then returned the isc license, but later stopped doing it.

This may have been it.

In commit https://github.com/nishanths/license/commit/49ed1a1b64e2387b15b104c341286c7b07571e02 in which the licenses were switched to being included in the binary instead of fetched at runtime, we see a lgpl-3.0 template added in the commit. The license list used at the time of the commit was obtained from the /licenses API at https://api.github.com/licenses (possibly with header Accept: application/vnd.github.v3+json). I think this means lgpl-3.0 was being returned by the API around the time of the commit. But right now the API doesn't include lgpl-3.0.

Something similar may have happened with isc as well, except that its removal in the GitHub API happened even before commit 49ed1a1.

ghost commented 2 years ago

Ah that makes sense, no worries then, glad I caught it then.

ghost commented 2 years ago

Huh, fun fact, the Github API still has ICS lying around, it's just not listed. Makes you wonder what other licenses are supported by the API but not listed 🤔

https://api.github.com/licenses/isc