niu-lab / msisensor2

Microsatellite instability (MSI) detection for tumor only data.
GNU General Public License v3.0
88 stars 21 forks source link

Output problem #4

Open xin8you opened 4 years ago

xin8you commented 4 years ago

Hi, I have some questions while using the msisensor2,I specify 27 sites for input, and only 7 sites have enough coverage (show below): image But, the distribution of read counts as below: image So, I don't understand what happened, can you help me, thanks!

owehann commented 4 years ago

Have you ever set the -c parameter ? Can you show me your whole command ?

xin8you commented 4 years ago

Have you ever set the -c parameter ? Can you show me your whole command ? @Beifang Hi, Beifang. Command line : msisensor2 msi -M models_hg19/ -d 27_marker_microsatellites.list -t test1.bam -p 5 -o msi I have set the -c from 0 to 20, but the results are the same.

Beifang commented 4 years ago

By using machine learning, only hypersensitie microsatellite sites were singled out for MSI detection. So, there are only 7 sites overlap between 27 sites you specified and msisensor2 model set. By our robustness test, the msisensor2 algorithm is effective with >= 5 random sites for WES data with >=0.99 AUC. So, 7 sites should works for you. We will change the output message to prevent misunderstanding in msisensor2.

xin8you commented 4 years ago

@Beifang, thank you very much for your detailed explanation! But, I have another question:

Beifang commented 4 years ago

I totally understand and appreciate your concerns. Several users have asked us to realease the models for 7 PCR golden standard markers ( BAT25/26, NR21/22/24/27, MONO27 ) soon. So, don't worry about that and we will add these 7 markers in hg19/38 model sets. Yes, we can send the 27 models for your test if you provide us the list.

xin8you commented 4 years ago

@Beifang Here is the 27 sites list in hg19. Thank you very much for your patient answer. 27_marker_microsatellites.txt

Beifang commented 4 years ago

@Beifang Here is the 27 sites list in hg19. Thank you very much for your patient answer. 27_marker_microsatellites.txt

Beifang commented 4 years ago

@Beifang Here is the 27 sites list in hg19. Thank you very much for your patient answer. 27_marker_microsatellites.txt

7 PCR golden standard markers and 10 sites from your 27 site list can not be captured by common WES or target capture assays. We provide the other 17 models for you :

msisensor2 msi -M ./test/tmp/models_hg19_17sites -t xxx.hg19.bam -o output.tumor.prefix

xin8you commented 4 years ago

@Beifang Thank you very much for your team's help! when other account use these new model, I found the permissions needed to write, but just have read only. Maybe you forgot to change permissions. Thanks for your nice help again.

Beifang commented 4 years ago

Could you please check your command line to make sure it is correct ? and make sure your account has permission as well.

Medard87 commented 3 years ago

Hi, I have similar problem like xin8you, I am trying to determine msi status in BAT25, BAT26, MonoC, NR22/24/27/21, CAT25 and D5S346 using msisensor2. Are STL 3D model files avilable for these sites (or for any of them) anywhere to download? Thank You

wyy1234-github commented 2 years ago

@xin8you can you tell me how to calculate repeat_unit_binary, left_flank_binary, right_flank_binary? I want to use the 7 PCR golden standard markers in tumor-control model.

Thank you.