V3.0.2 keeps crashing [bug]

Lajota1 commented 3 months ago

Description

So MMF V3.0.2 keeps crashing and getting back all the time, mainly when a use the scroll wheel a lot. The app will stop working and the icon at the top will disappear, a few seconds later it will reappear and start to work again. Sonoma 14.5.

Steps to reproduce

1- Use the scroll wheel a lot

Context

Mac Mouse Fix Version: 3.0.2 macOS Version: Sonoma 14.5 Mouse Model: Viper V2 Pro

Additional Comments

–

Console Logs

void _updateToReflectAutomaticTerminationState(void) Setting _kLSApplicationWouldBeTerminatedByTALKey=1

Crash Reports

https://pastebin.com/YeeVjKZz

plttn commented 3 months ago

Seeing this crashing still on my end as well.

I've had to switch to another scroll wheel reverser for the time being as it's nearly unusable. 😢

Lajota1 commented 3 months ago

Seeing this crashing still on my end as well.

I've had to switch to another scroll wheel reverser for the time being as it's nearly unusable. 😢

I bought the license but the crashes are so constant that its unusable. With one are you using?

plttn commented 3 months ago

Seeing this crashing still on my end as well. I've had to switch to another scroll wheel reverser for the time being as it's nearly unusable. 😢

I bought the license but the crashes are so constant that its unusable. With one are you using?

Given that this is a support forum for a product, I'm going to refrain from mentioning competitors, but there are absolutely other mouse wheel reversers in the market at the moment.

cloudgazing commented 3 months ago

Jumping in maybe I can help. The main version 3.0.2 has some issues and for now noah-nuebling released two more versions in #875. I'm on Sonoma 14.5 using a Razer Basilisk v3 and vcoba-2 has been almost flawless for me. Maybe you can try one of those, hopefully that fixes it.

Lajota1 commented 3 months ago

Jumping in maybe I can help. The main version 3.0.2 has some issues and for now noah-nuebling released two more versions in #875. I'm on Sonoma 14.5 using a Razer Basilisk v3 and vcoba-2 has been almost flawless for me. Maybe you can try one of those, hopefully that fixes it.

Been testing for a while, so far no crashes. Will update if crashes persist, thanks!

edit: so, unfortunately the crashes persist with vcoba-2, but it is more stable and the crashes happen less often. I'd say it is usable, but far from ideal.

edit 2: the standard vcoba (not the vcoba-2) is solid, working flawlessly until now, will test further and update if there are any crashes.

plttn commented 3 months ago

vcoba2 seems to work well for me.

noah-nuebling commented 3 months ago

Hey guys, thanks for your feedback!

I'm currently looking into this. I looked at the crash report and it seems the crash comes from this line of code according to my symbolication.

I've never ever seen this on my computer, and I'm just studying the code but it's really weird that this happens. Especially that you report "constant crashes", when I've never encountered this is strange.

I also don't understand why this would only happen on the v-coba builds.

I'm building some workarounds so the app can recover when it gets into this weird state, but hopefully I can figure out more.

noah-nuebling commented 3 months ago

Also I have some questions, that might help get to the bottom of this:

Do you guys frequently use the "Swift Scroll" modifier?
Do the crashes typically happen when your computer is really slow?
What computer model are you guys using?
Any other patterns you noticed about when the crashes happen?

If someone else with the issue can share their crash reports that would also be really interesting. The one from @Lajota1 has already been very helpful.

noah-nuebling commented 3 months ago

Oh and if you guys want I'd like to give anyone affected by this a refund. Just shoot me an email.

plttn commented 3 months ago

@noah-nuebling to clarify, the crashing doesn't occur on vcoba builds for me.

You should also have crash logs submitted by me from April 2, 2024.

noah-nuebling commented 3 months ago

Hey @plttn, thanks for getting back. That's interesting that you don't have the issue on the vcoba-2 build, but @Lajota1 still experiences crashes on vcoba-2. Thanks for clarifying that.

I looked at your crash report and it's consistent with the one that @Lajota1 shared. So that's also very helpful.

plttn commented 3 months ago

To answer the questions:

Do you guys frequently use the "Swift Scroll" modifier?

Never

Do the crashes typically happen when your computer is really slow?

As far as I'm aware no, (also because my Mac is a 64 gig of RAM model)

What computer model are you guys using?

M1 Max 2TB/64GB

Any other patterns you noticed about when the crashes happen?

Just scrolling is enough to cause it to crash.

noah-nuebling commented 3 months ago

@plttn thanks for getting back!

Are you guys using the Smoothness: Regular setting?

plttn commented 3 months ago

@plttn thanks for getting back!

Are you guys using the Smoothness: Regular setting?

I'm using Smoothness: High

noah-nuebling commented 3 months ago

@plttn oh that's very interesting!

From my understanding so far, I thought the crash happens inside code that is only executed when using Smoothness: Regular. Have you been using Smoothness: Regular around the time you experienced the crash that you sent to me?

plttn commented 3 months ago

@plttn oh that's very interesting!

From my understanding so far, I thought the crash happens inside code that is only executed when using Smoothness: Regular. Have you been using Smoothness: Regular around the time you experienced the crash that you sent to me?

As far as I know I've been using smoothness high since it released.

mhaeuser commented 2 months ago

Same issue here, definitely using Smoothness High (and Trackpad Simulation, macOS speed, inverse direction). I'm on M3 Pro. The issue started happening yesterday out of the blue, I haven't had anything alike since I started using Mac Mouse Fix (still in the v2 era). I sometimes use SHIFT-scrolling, but it is not required to trigger the bug.

I see you pushed workarounds to recover from the bug - any idea when you might release it? Thanks!

plttn commented 1 month ago

@noah-nuebling any plans to release a non-beta version with these fixes yet? I've been stuck on 3.0.2-vcoba2 since my initial crash reports.

noah-nuebling commented 1 week ago

Hey guys, I plan to release a fix tonight or tomorrow with the 3.0.3 release!

I was working on improving the localization system across the project, and I sort of got tunnel-visioned on that. I'm really sorry it took me so long to address this.

I've never experienced this crash even though I tried to reproduce it to catch it in the debugger for a while. And I'm still not sure what could lead to the internal conditions in the app that caused the crash. But if those conditions occur, the app should smoothly recover under 3.0.3 instead of crashing.

For now, the workaround in 3.0.3 should work ok, but if I want to work on the scrolling system in the future, it might be really valuable to understand this better.

If anybody's still experiencing these crashes (or if you did still experience them when you were last using 3.0.2) it would be really valuable if you sent your config.plist file so I can have a look at it.

The config.plist file holds pretty much all settings and state that is retained between launches of the app. You can find it like this:

Open Mac Mouse Fix
Go to the 'About' tab
Click the Mac Mouse Fix Icon while holding Command (⌘) and Shift (⇧). This should reveal the 'config.plist' file in the Finder.

Thank you, for your help.

mhaeuser commented 1 week ago

Thanks for the update! Is there any chance a macOS bug or odd behaviour could be contributing? I cannot reproduce the issue on macOS 15.1 Beta 4 right now (on 3.0.2 of course).

noah-nuebling commented 1 week ago

@mhaeuser That's an definitely a possibility that I hadn't considered before. It would be very interesting to hear whether you start seeing the crashes again, or whether it stays crash-free under 15.1.

mxalbert1996 commented 1 week ago

I experienced crashes on 3.0.2, so here's my config.plist. config.plist.zip

noah-nuebling commented 1 week ago

@mxalbert1996 I can't spot anything weird with that config.plist file after a quick check, but I'll use it with 3.0.2 for a while to see if I might be able to reproduce the crashes. Thanks very much!

noah-nuebling / mac-mouse-fix