notofonts / math

Noto Math
SIL Open Font License 1.1
25 stars 4 forks source link

Alpha and kappa are a bit too close to their latin lookalikes #71

Open Enivex opened 4 months ago

Enivex commented 4 months ago

image

From left to right: a, alpha, k, kappa

Both could use some further "flourishes" to make them more distinct.

khaledhosny commented 4 months ago

For italic a, we can switch to double storey variant. Not sure what to do for san-serif k/kappa.

khaledhosny commented 4 months ago

78:

image

80:

image
berrymot commented 4 months ago

i think changing the shape of alpha would be better than having two story a. something more like image maybe

khaledhosny commented 4 months ago

Feel free to submit such a change.

berrymot commented 4 months ago

how does one edit a .glyph? (new to this, sorry)

MAZ06 commented 4 months ago

You mean a sans version of this? image This is from Noto Serif LGC.

berrymot commented 4 months ago

basically yeah

MAZ06 commented 4 months ago

Maybe @Mercury13 could draw it.

simoncozens commented 4 months ago

This was closed automatically when the kappa PR was merged, but alpha is still open.

MAZ06 commented 4 months ago

I was surprised to see the lowercase alpha so similar to the lowercase a. If a new sans alpha is drawn, I suggest it get added to Noto Sans LGC as the default glyph and the current sans alpha be moved to being an alternative.

moyogo commented 4 months ago

The Greek in Noto Sans was updated a couple of years ago. Are those not adequate?

MAZ06 commented 4 months ago

Wow that was a fast reply!

The Greek in Noto Sans seems adequate to me. Obviously a Greek speaker would read the lowercase alpha correctly, but I feel like a lowercase alpha should look closer to its Noto Serif counterpart. At least in my opinion.

What do the Unicode docs say about it?

Mercury13 commented 4 months ago

@MAZ06 is absolutely right. Need mathematical alpha.

khaledhosny commented 4 months ago

The Greek in Noto Sans was updated a couple of years ago. Are those not adequate?

We seem to be using a mix of the old and new Greek, I opened https://github.com/notofonts/math/issues/81 to track this.