novus-package-manager / novus

A blazingly fast and efficient package manager for windows.
https://novuspkg.com
Apache License 2.0
211 stars 3 forks source link

Contains features and ideas identical to / directly from Electric w/o credit / mention #3

Closed suptejas closed 3 years ago

suptejas commented 3 years ago

From what I have seen, Novus uses a lot of ideas that seem to be copied heavily inspired / directly copied from Electric.

Here are a few examples:

1. Package Name Autocorrection

image

vs image

2. Auto Elevating the User image

vs

image

3. Temp Directory Folder Structure image

vs

image

Although it is natural to copy features from direct competitors, it is unethical not to credit or at the least, point out that these features are inspired by Electric. Hope this can be addressed soon 👍.

tejas186 commented 3 years ago

Um, yes. Giving credit/mention is the least that can be done

aaryamvn commented 3 years ago

I completely agree with you. The Novus website seems heavily inspired by https://hydralite.io and https://www.covisource.in as well, two projects I worked/am working on. As an open-source project, I understand how this may seem alright to do, however, it's unethical in the face of software development. Please attend to this whenever possible, and at least credit the platforms you were inspired by.

Angshu31 commented 3 years ago

Most features seem to be very similar - too similar. Credit should be given at the very least

0xPranavDoshi commented 3 years ago

I have looked at this issue, and I have given credits to Electric and Chocolatey as it inspired me to build Novus. I have also mentioned hydralite as an inspiration for the website theme

There always might be some similarities in products trying to solve similar problems. For example, atom and sublime text, gimp and photoshop, google docs and ms word, etc will all have similar features.

With this in mind, I assure you that the Novus codebase was developed independently.

suptejas commented 3 years ago

@ZaphodElevated thanks for looking into this - would appreciate if you could link the CREDITS.md to the readme under a credits heading, most people end up going through the README instead of casually browsing code files.