search

numixproject / numix-core

Builder for App Icon Themes
GNU General Public License v3.0
768 stars 146 forks source link

Icons for AVI MetaEdit #5555

Closed maxtron95 closed 4 years ago

maxtron95 commented 4 years ago

https://mediaarea.net/AVIMetaEdit

(Yes, that is literally the original icon.) net mediaarea AVIMetaEdit

avimetaedit-ci avimetaedit-sq

Foggalong commented 4 years ago

(Yes, that is literally the original icon.)

This is disgraceful. A prime example both of why the argument "icon themes encroach on developer branding" is invalid; it presupposes that developers always put thought into their icon design which as we've seen time and time again isn't the case.

maxtron95 commented 4 years ago

@Foggalong I apologize for being rude, I was reckless with that comment. If it was directed at me.

Foggalong commented 4 years ago

@creepertron95 No not at all! I meant the original icon was disgraceful, you've done absolutely nothing wrong :smile:

maxtron95 commented 4 years ago

@Foggalong Oh ok, I see what you mean, On the topic of this icon, as I saw what good icon design looks like, Why would they choose the National Archives logo as their icon? It doesn't even hint at what the app is supposed to do.

Foggalong commented 4 years ago

Honestly no idea - it's an app for verifying/editing meta data from the archive footage, but even then it's not a great link