search

nursoda / twofactor_email

Nextcloud 2FA Provider that uses e-mail as transport
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
25 stars 11 forks source link

Nextcloud 29+30 Support #376

Closed ghost closed 3 days ago

ghost commented 8 months ago

Support for NC 29

naelfe commented 7 months ago

Yes please. Discovered it did not work when trying to log in after the update

mmccarn commented 6 months ago

I don't know if there is a reason for the delay.

Info.xml was updated with <nextcloud min-version="24" max-version="29" /> on Mar 28 (but there have been no other changes since November...)

Two-Factor Email works for me if I force-enable it.

nursoda commented 6 months ago

I currently cannot build a Version that does not throw security warnings. I wait for an answer from Nextcloud.

If anyone can help out, please reach out!

I also had the app rebased on twofactor_TOTP, new version probably will be based on v3, available at https://github.com/datenschutz-individuell/twofactor_email

pov91 commented 5 months ago

Are there any news, when a regular update is to be expected? 2FA is quite a standard these days, so Nextcloud should be interested in fixing the problem promptly. Thus, an update for a production system where users have set that is impossible.

TheRaven500 commented 5 months ago

@nursoda: Who needs to be poked to get things moving? :smiley:

nursoda commented 5 months ago

Best would be if anyone with JS experience could offer me some time. Contact see olav.seyfarth.de

pov91 commented 5 months ago

I hope you can find a helping hand. Thank you for taking care of the app. Is an important function. Unfortunately, I cannot help you.

michal0202 commented 5 months ago

Any news on this topic?

42ske commented 3 months ago

Is there any realistic estimation when we could expect the app to be running with NC 29?

rdlab-upc commented 2 months ago

Hello,

Fist of all thank you for the app, we know it is built and maintained by your own means.

@mmccarn Info.xml was updated with on Mar 28 (but there have been no other changes since November...)

Please, can you confirm this "workaround" still works on NC 29? Any issues/warnings? Anyone else? @AndyXheli @naelfe @pov91 @michal0202 @42ske

@nursoda I also had the app rebased on twofactor_TOTP, new version probably will be based on v3, available at https://github.com/datenschutz-individuell/twofactor_email

Any estimation about it? AFAIK this code cannot be installed from the NC appstore and we will not dare to replace the pluging files.


Sadly we can only provide you IT infrastructure/admin support, programming is out of our expertise. Let us know if it can help you anyway.


Thank you.

DazeEnd commented 2 months ago

I also had the app rebased on twofactor_TOTP, new version probably will be based on v3, available at https://github.com/datenschutz-individuell/twofactor_email

@rdlab-upc Are you saying that you have put together a version of twofactor_TOTP that sends the code by email instead of using TOTP? If that’s correct, I encourage you to contact the twofactor_TOTP team to share your work for possible long-term integration.

rdlab-upc commented 2 months ago

@DazeEnd We made some tests, unfortunately our integration was not successful for v29 and we also care for collateral issues due the replacement of the original code.

That's why we ask for any advance in the v29/30 support.

nursoda commented 2 months ago

I apologize for the delay. I had a working version, but I broke it somehow. So, yes, there will be a version for v29+ soon. No promises on the day, but it will be shortly after the v30 release.

bigcat88 commented 2 months ago

sorry for the spam, but is there any news on this?

DazeEnd commented 3 days ago

@nursoda I know this is a volunteer effort and you don’t owe anyone anything, but now that this issue is closed as “not planned”, can you provide a status update? Is this plugin not going to be updated? Is it effectively unmaintained? Or has this issue been superseded by another issue I missed? I just would like to be able to make a plan for upgrading.

In case it helps, I renew my offer of financial support if you are still needing to hire a developer to get this across the finish line.

nursoda commented 3 days ago

Dear Charles, thanks for offering that (again)! It's also good to hear that the app is used and users to care. I do feel bad for letting everyone down for so long (including my own instances, so I also do feel the urge. While I did try, life's had other plans with me.

Looking forward: This app is not dead, but this 'nursoda' repo will not see a version for NC >28. Development now is in https://github.com/datenschutz-individuell/twofactor_email/ This issue probably shouldn't have been just closed without comment but moved there.

Anyway: I'll contact you if I do need financial support. At the moment, it's rather lack of time.

Zottel92 commented 2 days ago

@nursoda Thank you for your efforts to bring this forward and providing this important feature. Maybe it would make sense to pin this closed issue here. That would make it more clear for future readers that this Repo will be migrated.

lightonflux commented 1 day ago

Thanks for the clear communication @nursoda, I too suggest pinning this issue and archiving this repo, to improve the messaging about the state of this repo. Thanks for your work on the app and all the best for your future!