search

nus-cs2103-AY2122S2 / forum

13 stars 1 forks source link

Question regarding bugs on diagram #284

Open Punpun1643 opened 2 years ago

Punpun1643 commented 2 years ago

Hi prof, in the report received, there is a bug in one of the diagrams in the DG. The tester has provided a screenshot of the diagram in which I also agree that there is something wrong with the diagram. However, the tester's explanation of his/her argument on why the diagram is wrong is not correct either (i.e. the diagram is really wrong, but it should not be corrected in the way the tester has described; correcting it in the way that the tester has described would still be wrong).

In this case, should I still reject the report?

damithc commented 2 years ago

@Punpun1643 if the bug report is good enough for you to detect there's a problem with the diagram, the bug report has achieved its main purpose. Proposing a fix is not strictly the tester's job. So, you can accept the bug but mention in your response that you don't agree with the proposed solution.

Punpun1643 commented 2 years ago

Alright prof @damithc, that makes sense. Thank you for the clarification!