search

nus-cs2103-AY2324S2 / forum

16 stars 0 forks source link

Query on PE bug #885

Closed Li-Zizhen closed 6 months ago

Li-Zizhen commented 7 months ago

If the program can do something more than specified in the user guide, is that an error?

Example 1: If my input contains two 'n/' and the program runs but only uses the first name input. Is this an error?

Or

Example 2: the UG says inputting student INDEX can delete the student, but I found out inputting student ID can also delete the student. Is this an error?

Or

Example 3: The UG says use a or d to sort, however I found A and D are also valid input, is this error?

damithc commented 7 months ago

@Li-Zizhen we don't want to pre-judge specific cases until the tester and the dev team had a chance to give their opinion. That said, in some cases the app doing something the UG does not mention can be considered a documentation bug, unless the missing info is considered obvious and not worth specifying.

Li-Zizhen commented 6 months ago

Thank you.