nus-cs2103-AY2324S2 / forum

16 stars 0 forks source link

Is weird email out of scope or feature flaw? #928

Closed chiageng closed 6 months ago

chiageng commented 6 months ago

Hi prof, our team has received this error as "medium feature flaw"

image

As his justification is that this is one valid email that exists in real world. May i know whether is this considered out of scope as we dont really know this type of case beforehand.

damithc commented 6 months ago

@chiageng In general, rejecting valid inputs is not desirable. 'We didn't know about it' is not strictly a valid excuse, but the probability of actual usage can be used to determine severity and whether it can be NotInScope. For example, low probability of usage can be used to justify a lower severity, or lower priority to support it in the current version.

Also related: image

chiageng commented 6 months ago

Okay thank you prof.