search

nuxt-modules / i18n

I18n module for Nuxt
https://i18n.nuxtjs.org
MIT License
1.71k stars 478 forks source link

Permission for using cookies #2821

Open Posoroko opened 7 months ago

Posoroko commented 7 months ago

Describe the feature

Because it is illegal ( in the EU, at least ) to set cookies on a user's machine without asking for the right permission first, it would be very usefull to have the i18n module to not set any cookie before the permission has been granted.

I've researched a solution to this problem, and I've found nothing.

In the i18n config, we could specify a cookie name that needs to exist before the module actually sets the cookie.

Additional information

Final checks

Mat4m0 commented 7 months ago

From what I know, it is allowed that you can set cookies without consent as long as they are technical and are necessary for the site to function. To show the user the right language is, in my opinion, 100% technical and necessary for a site to function.

Source: (German) https://www.datenschutz.org/dsgvo-cookies/

Translated:

  • When does the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) allow cookies?

If their use involves the processing of personal data, cookies are only permitted under certain conditions under the General Data Protection Regulation. According to the GDPR, a website may only use cookies that are not technically necessary if the user has consented to this.

  • Which cookies must be pointed out?

In principle, reference must be made to all cookies that are not technically necessary to ensure the operation of a website. A mere reference to their use is not sufficient, as the user must first expressly consent to their use. How cookie settings can be made GDPR-compliant is explained in more detail here.

  • Which cookies may be set without consent?

Consent is not required for cookies that are technically necessary to provide the basic functions of a website. However, a GDPR-compliant cookie consent tool or cookie banner must offer the user the option to choose between necessary and non-necessary cookies.

Posoroko commented 7 months ago

@Mat4m0 Thanks for your response. I feel this is a tough subject because it's fair to pretend that some people wouldn't want any cookie to be set locally. I personally find it weird that a website I only visit once ( to read about animating a border in css ) would store a cookie to remember my preferred language.

Is it exaggerated to image that we could ask permission before using the local storage in any way ?

I'm ok with the idea of some cookies being "basic site functionality" ... but as a dev, I feel it would be nice to be able to make cookies conditional to the user's decision.