nvk / walletsrecovery.org

Information about wallet defaults for external recovery
https://walletsrecovery.org/
115 stars 96 forks source link

Suggestions about emojis #131

Open andronoob opened 3 years ago

andronoob commented 3 years ago
Icon Legend Notes
βœ… Documented + Link to doc Just keep it as-is. (I also think (the first 4 rows which represents documentation status, or maybe include other as well) rows should be sorted here, like, from best status to worse status)
πŸ”Ž (πŸ”) Known, but unofficially documented In this situation, recovery info can be googled, so I think the magnifying glass πŸ”Ž should be accurate.
❓(or😡) Unknown. No obvious docs, research in progress The question mark ❓ generally represents "unknown". As for 😡, I just think the stop sign πŸ›‘ fits more in the next "abandoned project" situation, while the dizzy face 😡 fits more in this situation, however I still recommend the question mark emoji here.
☠️ Not publicly available, or complex without a external tool available for the average user Just keep it as-is.
🏚️(orπŸ›‘) Discontinued and/or no longer maintained 🏚️ is the "derelict house", which was the first result of googling "abandon emoji" (it's the most accurate in my opinion!), however it might not be seemingly very clear or intuitive, so I think the stop sign πŸ›‘ might fit in this situation as well.
πŸ”“ HW Physically unsafe with β€œfull secret” (ie without BIP39 passphrase or multisig) against a automated attack and/or unsophisticated attacker (ie chipshouter blackbox) πŸ”“ is the "unlocked padlock", which can represent lack of security.
πŸ‘ Privacy concerns (default is third party node) Just keep it as-is.
⛓️ Validation concerns (default is third party node) Although β‘‚ is the "fork" unicode character, which accurately represents what it should represent here, I still think it seems to stand out here because it's not a emoji. However I felt difficult to find accurate emoji as well. ⛓️ should represent "blockchain" here.
Enegnei commented 3 years ago

I approve. @nvk?

nvk commented 3 years ago

Sure, I like them. The ⛓️ still a bit unclear. I wish they had a fork🍴 only emoji.

Alternatives:

nvk commented 2 years ago

@Enegnei still interested in making these changes? I've added one more for "New projects/teams" with the idea of extra scrutiny to be observed.