Closed 317070 closed 7 years ago
I don't understand your comment?
You can 2-move into and out of the sea. I've never been able to remember this. At the very least, your change now makes it symmetric, but I still don't like 2-moves involving sea regions, because of non-intuitiveness. Even though I like lots of mobility.
@nymanjens don't forget this is experimental branch. Unless you see a good reason why this change is bad and doesn't deserve an experimental playtest, I would approve it.
This particular issue has been suggested many times before, so I think this makes perfect sense to add to experimental and actually experience whether the current 'road'-rule is worth its additional complexity.
I think this change is a small simplification but not a large one. Also, I don't like that you can use this starting from the sea. That said, I don't like any sea-specific exceptions to this rule, because it again complicates things.
Anyway, since it's the experimental branch, I guess that is an argument to be more lenient. On the other hand, I don't think we'll have a way of determining whether this is a good change after one or two test games (I think the arguments are going to be the same).
Well, it is simpler.
If after one or two games, we have no way of determining if there is a difference, then maybe there is no difference? When there is no difference, then maybe we should go for the simpler option?
Robin and I have already played like 15-20 games with this rule, and we still find it confusing.
If after one or two games, we have no way of determining if there is a difference, then maybe there is no difference?
This is not what I meant. There will likely be a small difference, but the same arguments will be made after as before.
I thought some more about this and changed my mind. I think this could be a better rule. I'm only worried about sea-land-land moves. Let's test-play it.
2 persons worried about sea-land-land moves. Are we going to add an exception for that before test-play (no double-moves involving sea)? Or are we going to go for the current version?
TBH, if we are going to make an exception for the sea, I would opt to maybe stick to the current rule. So I would try this version first. Is that OK @Tantali ?
I'm with Jonas here
On the experimental branch