Define which elements have `id`

oasis-tcs / lexidma

OASIS Lexicographic Infrastructure Data Model and API (LEXIDMA) TC: A repository designed for use in development of TC chartered work products and test suites. https://github.com/oasis-tcs/lexidma

Other

7 stars 8 forks source link

Define which elements have `id` #65

Closed jmccrae closed 10 months ago

jmccrae commented 11 months ago

It is not defined in the standard which elements have an id.

Some elements cannot have id (partOfSpeech and label) as this would not be represent-able in JSON and RDF serialization

Issue arose during implementation of #61

DavidFatDavidF commented 10 months ago

We explain non-normatively in the abstract model why some objects have ids in the abstract model and some serializations, we will not be adding new ids to the model, we will have this as an implementation Note in the abstract data model @michmech to implement by January 3

michmech commented 10 months ago

Actually, no objects have IDs at the model level.
In the JSON, XML and NVH serializations, there are three object types that can have IDs: entries, senses and collocate markers. The purpose and the only function of the IDs is to allow them to appear as members of relations. I have updated the text to say that these three object types have IDs only if implementing the Liking module.

Will close automatically when pull request #75 is merged.