search

oasis-tcs / openc2-oc2ls

OASIS OpenC2 TC: GitHub repository used to propose and track changes to the OpenC2 Language Specification as new working draft level revisions are created and the associated CSDs mature
https://github.com/oasis-tcs/openc2-oc2ls
Other
15 stars 19 forks source link

Is Actuator correct word? #398

Closed sparrell closed 1 year ago

sparrell commented 2 years ago

The word actuator was discussed at a working meeting a few weeks ago. Apparently the word causes some misunderstandings. Changing would be a breaking fix (ie would cause to increment to V2.0). Initial proposal was to defer for awhile but consensus was reached that it would be better to do sooner rather than later.

What should the word be?

The language spec defines actuator:

Actuator: The function performed by the Consumer that executes the Command (e.g.,
'Stateless Packet Filtering').

If you have a proposed word to replace it, add a comment below. If you like one of the alternatives someone put below, then give it a thumbs up. If you are against a particular word, give it a thumbs down.

sparrell commented 2 years ago

Leave it as is with 'actuator"

sparrell commented 2 years ago

'actor'

sparrell commented 2 years ago

'function'

sparrell commented 2 years ago

'functional component'

sparrell commented 2 years ago

"executor"

sparrell commented 2 years ago

"performer"

sparrell commented 2 years ago

"agent"

sparrell commented 2 years ago

"action doer"

davaya commented 2 years ago

profile

dlemire60 commented 2 years ago

This was discussed at the 8/3 working meeting, and @davaya clarified that the real issue is the use of the term "actuator" in the specification where "profile" would be more appropriate. This will be a breaking change, as it affects the message content definition, and should be handled promptly. @davaya will be preparing a corresponding PR.