oasis-tcs / sarif-spec

OASIS SARIF TC: Repository for development of the draft standard, where requests for modification should be made via Github Issues
https://github.com/oasis-tcs/sarif-spec
Other
163 stars 46 forks source link

Proposal: change underlying name of SARIF from Static ... to Systematic ... #603

Open Motional-Charles-Wilson opened 10 months ago

Motional-Charles-Wilson commented 10 months ago

For the next major release of SARIF the underlying name should be changed from Static Analysis Report Interchange Format to Systematic Analysis Report Interchange Format. This would better reflect the scope and applicability of the standard. This change would be in support of the additional non-static analysis use cases being recommended for support in the next major revision.

sthagen commented 8 months ago

I think we discussed this over a year ago in quite some length weighing charter change needs against good naming effects. I remember we decided to postpone until publication of the errata (which is now passed).

I am in favor of discussing this issue but I am -1 o the "Systematic" as this sounds to me too sales like similar to "Clean" or "Optimal" ... but we will find for sure the best path forward for the SARIF ... I think it is simple as long as the first word starts with "S" or has an "s" at a prominent place (as the "x" in "Extensible" Markup Language --> XML)

Amending the proposal:

I would be OK with a term like:

Software Analysis Report Interchange Format (SARIF)

or

System Analysis Report Interchange Format (SARIF)

with a slight preference for the latter.

davidmalcolm commented 6 months ago

Some possible candidates that begin with an "s":

davidmalcolm commented 21 hours ago

Did we decide on "System" here?

sthagen commented 18 hours ago

@davidmalcolm Yes, System it is. We documented that decision in Minutes from TC meeting 2024-06-06 in section 5.2 "Review of Decisions Reached" (as the third of three decisions noted).