Open DitchingIt opened 1 year ago
Just a note to add a resource:
Having reviewed the stress related behavior sub-branch #123, I can see that this thread has the potential to generate questions about the NBO styles and conventions. I have copied a note from my review as a contribution to the general thinking:
Attached is my proposed Convention sheet for editing old and adding new classes. It should be referenced in the contributing.md but doesn't change anything there (except the emphasis which needs to be a little stronger if we agree to use this as a touchstone). Conventions 230128.pdf
See #16 regarding vague definitions.
I have drafted an updated Definition Conventions Reference Sheet. In particular it
It was pointed out to me recently that whereas it's easy to disjoint a term in another ontology, doing so may actually affect how the other ontology works. Unless discussion here changes things, I propose:
Nice initiative!! And, I am sure, quite lonely. Sorry I only see this now, if you need help on anything ping me!
The current Ethology module editing project principally focuses on editing what exists within the NBO and only adding new terms which help with its interpretation.
A future project needs to look at adding new terms not just for the sake of taxonomic and habitat balance (if not completeness) but to tackle what Chris Mungall calls the single-child anti-pattern and the single-child-by-axis pattern.
Whereas I am withdrawing from working on the NBO (see #124 ), I strongly recommend that the conventions sheet developed as part of this issue be adopted by any future editor, unless it be amended by consensus.
Most of the original structure for the NBO was created over a decade ago. I have been looking at where things are currently and some of the contents may need a bit of a dusting. In particular, I am interested in four contributions to developing principles:
I would like to have a go at reviewing a sub-branch of the process branch and see what comments people have. If that seems worthwhile, I will put it as a new issue and keep this issue for a general discussion about labels and definitions in NBO.