obophenotype / human-phenotype-ontology

Ontology for the description of human clinical features
http://obophenotype.github.io/human-phenotype-ontology/
Other
291 stars 51 forks source link

Suggestion to merge Heterotopia and gray matter heterotopias #4508

Closed pnrobinson closed 5 years ago

pnrobinson commented 5 years ago

Related to https://github.com/obophenotype/human-phenotype-ontology/issues/4382 Renske, are you basically say that "Gray matter heterotopia" is a synonym for "Heteropia"?

On of the annotated diseases is Chudley-mccullough Syndrome. According to COST:neuromig, this disease is characterized by Mesial parasagittal subcortical heterotopia. (The current OMIM annotation is Subcortical nodular gray matter heterotopia). Another annotated disease is FraX sundrome, which currently is annotated to Periventricular heterotopia in OMIM. We should revise all of these annotations in light of the new terms.

Renske-Oegema commented 5 years ago

Yes, if they are in the brain they are, but heterotopic tissue can be present in / and consist of other tissue.

If these could potentially be confusing, we could go for gray matter heterotopia as the main term, but this term is not in use by our expert netwerk.

And these heterotopia in Chudley-mccullough Syndrome are not nodular.

"Another annotated disease is FraX sundrome, which currently is annotated to Periventricular heterotopia in OMIM." > you don't need to change it.

pnrobinson commented 5 years ago

Yes, because heterotopia can also be present in other organs/ tissues this is potentially confusing

Gray matter heterotopia are the same as neuronal heterotopia. Both terms can be used, I would prefer gray matter heterotopia, it is a bit more common and also more understandable to the lay.

I notice that the english vs american differs in the spelling of the word grey/ gray. Should we add both terms?

pnrobinson commented 5 years ago

merged these two. Also added the British spelling