Closed kit-ty-kate closed 4 years ago
Thanks a lot @kit-ty-kate , it seems you need to add the beta opam repos to the travis file?
Will merge ASAP, this need a changes.md entry [I can add it myself, or feel free to do it yourself]
@kit-ty-kate I see you did not update the opam file, should that also wait?
Umm, CI fails now, how bizarre, I think it worked before?
I think it did not work before, the CI wasn't triggered it seems. I'll fix it, sorry for that.
@kit-ty-kate I see you did not update the opam file, should that also wait?
Yup that made CI fail, what should we do?
Oops, sorry. Fixed.
Allowing to compile with later compiler should be ok as this package uses ocaml-migrate-parsetree. We'll constrain the package if necessary in opam-repository.
As for ppxlib
, I couldn't find any use of it in the source code. The dependency was apparently added in https://github.com/ocaml-ppx/ppx_import/pull/27 but never used.
Allowing to compile with later compiler should be ok as this package uses ocaml-migrate-parsetree. We'll constrain the package if necessary in opam-repository.
Actually ppx_import
uses some parts of the typed tree thus unfortunately ocaml-migrate-parsetree
doesn't fully capture the version-specific dependencies. Thus the < 4.12
constrain has to be kept.
See also https://github.com/ocaml-ppx/ocaml-migrate-parsetree/issues/52
Sure, but I'm not sure a potential breakage implies that every compiler has to be checked by hand. For instance if ppx_import
hadn't had the constraint I would've not have to do this PR (this PR only fixes a warning). Technically the previous version of ppx_import works with 4.11 if only the constraint was removed.
Given the hard dependency ppx_import
has on OCaml internals I'm not sure I'd feel comfortable not using an upper bound. I prefer the dependency set to be consistent over more general but potentially broken.
@kit-ty-kate , I did squash with the intention of merging, but it seems the opam solver cannot satisfy the dependencies in 4.11 ? Having a look locally.
The following dependencies couldn't be met:
- ppx_import → ppx_deriving >= 4.2.1 → ppx_tools >= 4.02.3 → ocaml < 4.11
base of this switch (use `--unlock-base' to force)
- ppx_import → ppx_deriving >= 4.2.1 → ocaml < 4.11.0
base of this switch (use `--unlock-base' to force)
No solution found, exiting
The command "opam install --deps-only -d -t ppx_import" exited with 20.
Yup, ppx_deriving
cannot be installed in 4.11, thus no way to run the test suite; I guess we'll have to wait until this is fixed.
ah right, this requires https://github.com/ocaml-ppx/ppx_tools/pull/82. Hopefully I'll make a new release by next week. If you want to test it locally you can use https://github.com/kit-ty-kate/opam-alpha-repository. There should be everything you need with that.
Currently ppx_import does not support OCaml 4.11. This PR fixes the issue