oemof / feedinlib

This repository contains implementations of photovoltaic models to calculate electricity generation from a pv installation based on given solar radiation. Furthermore it contains all necessary pre-calculations.
MIT License
102 stars 44 forks source link

Clarify differences and similarities to atlite #77

Open maurerle opened 1 year ago

maurerle commented 1 year ago

This project seems to have similar use cases as https://github.com/PyPSA/atlite

It would be very cool to have a summary of the similarities and differences on the README page.

Similarities:

Differences

I think the comparison here is also very interesting and would be very cool to compare the performance of the feedinlib towards atlite: https://github.com/PyPSA/atlite/blob/master/examples/historic-comparison-germany.ipynb

Would be cool if others could complete the list of features/similarities/differences :)

p-snft commented 1 year ago

As of today, oemof in general is developed mostly focussing on local energy systems (e.g. with a granularity that allows resolving at least individual urban areas). So, your assumption that single installations play a role is indeed true. In a combined workflow, we rather try to answer the question on which of the available roofs PV installations should be installed (first). For most of the active devs, the overall potential on a global scale is not so much of interest.

As you have noticed, feedinlib has also been used in the openFRED project (and there are models using solph that optimise the national scale energy system). To my knowledge, this is currently not the focus of most of the oemof devs, so I do not really see that someone here would contribute to a more detailed comparison with atlite.